The Absolute Best Pizza in Bexley [Updated 2025]

With the warm aroma of freshly baked dough wafting through the air and the vibrant colors of marinara and mozzarella dancing on my plate, I can confidently say that pizza is more than just a meal—it's a celebration! After countless tastings and a few delightful pizza-induced food comas, I've scoured 12 top locations in Bexley, each offering its own unique twist on this beloved dish.

You can trust my expertise because I’ve not only tasted every slice but also immersed myself in the stories behind these local pizzerias. From family recipes passed down through generations to innovative toppings that push the boundaries of tradition, I'm here to guide you through a pizza journey that promises to tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more. Let’s dive into the delicious world of Bexley’s best pizzas together!

Brassica in Bexley

Highlights
Healthy and delicious meals
Kind and attentive employees
Clean and inviting atmosphere
Great value for fresh food
Repeat customers love it

Brassica in Bexley is a delightful find, and as a self-proclaimed pizza aficionado, I couldn’t resist giving it a try. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere—clean and warm, it practically whispers, “Stay a while.” The kindness and attentiveness of the staff stole the show; their passion for pizza was palpable, adding a personal touch to my dining experience.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza! Brassica offers healthy and delicious options that cater to both the palate and the conscience. Each bite is a harmonious blend of fresh ingredients, and you can tell they take pride in crafting their meals. I was impressed by the variety they offer, striking a balance between tradition and innovation.

What truly sets Brassica apart is the value they provide—affordably priced for such high-quality food. It’s no wonder I spotted many repeat customers. Whether you're a seasoned pizza lover or trying it for the first time, Brassica is a must-visit. So gather your friends and take a trip to this gem in Bexley; you might just find your new favorite pie! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Yellow Brick

Highlights
Large NY style slices
Signature hand-tossed pizzas
Freshly cooked to order
Friendly and attentive staff
Pride in culinary quality

Yellow Brick has a whimsical charm that immediately draws you in. As I stepped inside, the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted over me like an inviting hug. This spot features large New York-style slices that are not only impressive in size but also generous with toppings. Their signature hand-tossed pizzas are a true labor of love, crafted with ingredients that burst with freshness.

What I found particularly delightful was the option to customize your pizza, ensuring each slice meets individual cravings. Every pizza is made fresh to order, which guarantees that each bite is piping hot and utterly satisfying. The combination of a perfectly crispy crust and the rich flavors of top-notch toppings makes for an unforgettable experience.

The friendly and attentive staff only enhances the atmosphere, making you feel right at home from the moment you walk in. It’s clear that they take immense pride in their culinary quality, and it shows in every artisanal slice.

If you find yourself in Bexley and craving pizza, do yourself a favor and stop by Yellow Brick. You’ll leave with a happy heart and a full belly, and that’s a guarantee!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Columbus.

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

Highlights
Exceptional fried pickles
Quick and friendly service
Tasty chicken Parmesan
Clean restaurant ambiance
Perfectly cooked burgers

Review of Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

Walking into Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern in Bexley is like stepping into a cozy family gathering. The atmosphere is inviting, with a clean and friendly vibe that instantly puts you at ease. As I settled into my seat, I couldn't resist the delightful aroma wafting through the air, enticing me to explore their pizza offerings.

The service was impressively quick and attentive, making my visit all the more enjoyable. I decided to pair my pizza with an order of their exceptional fried pickles, which were perfectly crispy and complemented my meal beautifully. The pizza itself was a marvelous delight— the crust was cooked to perfection, offering that ideal balance of chewiness and crunch. Topped with fresh ingredients that sang with flavor, each bite transported me to pizza heaven.

While Rusty Bucket is well-known for its delicious chicken Parmesan and perfectly cooked burgers, the pizza holds its own as a standout choice. This hidden gem in Bexley is not just a pizza place; it’s an experience filled with flavors and warmth. I left with a full belly and a big smile, already planning my next visit.

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Harvest Pizzeria Bexley

Nestled in the heart of Bexley, Harvest Pizzeria offers a delightful pizza experience that’s hard to resist. Their dough is a beautiful blend of chewiness and crispness, while the toppings are both fresh and flavorful—I opted for the Margherita, and it was love at first bite! The mozzarella was perfectly melted, creating a rich, creamy bite paired with the vibrant basil. What truly sets them apart is their cozy and inviting atmosphere, perfect for both casual outings and special occasions. If you're on the hunt for pizza happiness, Harvest Pizzeria is definitely worth a visit! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Rubinos Pizza

Rubinos Pizza in Bexley is a delightful hidden gem that tickled my taste buds! Upon entering, warm aromas of cheesy goodness enveloped me, instantly setting the stage for what was to come. Their signature pie, topped with fresh basil, succulent tomatoes, and a perfectly tangy sauce, was nothing short of a flavor explosion. The thin, crispy crust provided an ideal balance, making each bite a symphony of taste. The staff radiated warmth and passion for their craft, enhancing the cozy atmosphere. If you're seeking a slice of paradise, Rubinos is the place to be! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Bexley Pizza Plus

Nestled in the heart of Bexley, Bexley Pizza Plus is a delightful treasure for pizza enthusiasts! The crust has the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, delivering an irresistible bite. Their signature Margherita showcases fresh basil and a tomato sauce that bursts with flavor. I was particularly enchanted by the generous cheese pull, each slice practically begging to be devoured! The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff make it a great spot for family gatherings or casual hangouts. If you're on the hunt for a fantastic pizza experience, look no further than this charming pizzeria—it’s a slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Joe's Pizza

Stepping into Joe's Pizza felt like entering a slice of heaven. The aroma danced around me, beckoning me to try their signature pie. I opted for the classic Margherita, and it certainly didn’t disappoint! The crust was perfectly crispy yet chewy, while the fresh basil added a delightful twist to each bite. Their homemade tomato sauce was bursting with flavor, making it a must-try. The ambiance was friendly and inviting, enhancing the experience further. If you're hunting for a pizza paradise in Bexley, look no further than Joe's Pizza—it truly delivers a delectable indulgence!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Giuseppe's Ritrovo

Arriving at Giuseppe's Ritrovo, the aroma of freshly baked dough wafted through the air, instantly igniting my excitement. I opted for the classic Margherita, and it was a masterpiece! The thin, crisp crust had just the right amount of char, while the rich tomato sauce danced harmoniously with creamy mozzarella. Each bite was like a joyful celebration of flavor. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff made the experience even more delightful. If you're in Bexley and craving pizza, you truly can't go wrong at Giuseppe's—it’s a slice of heaven worth savoring! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Piada Italian Street Food

At Piada Italian Street Food, I was swept away by their vibrant ambiance and enticing aroma. The Neapolitan pizza was a standout—with a perfectly charred crust that balanced a delightful chewiness. Topped with luscious San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and fragrant basil, each bite felt like a culinary journey to Italy. The prices are surprisingly reasonable, making it a guilty pleasure that doesn’t break the bank. If you’re in the mood for a pizza that pays homage to authentic Italian flavors, Piada's got you covered. This gem surely deserves a spot in the conversation for Bexley’s best pizza! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

Scotty's Cafe

Stepping into Scotty's Cafe feels like being welcomed into a cozy friend's kitchen. Their pizza, a delightful harmony of flavor and freshness, boasts a perfect crust that strikes the balance between crispy and chewy. The house-made sauce is a tomato lover's dream, bursting with herbs that dance on the palate. I savored the Margherita, which was a vibrant canvas of fresh mozzarella and basil, reminding me of sunny Italian summers. If you’re looking for a slice that warms the soul, Scotty’s is an absolute must-try in Bexley! Whether you're a local or just passing through, don’t miss out!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Donatos Pizza

At Donatos Pizza, I was greeted by their signature thin-crust delight, which made my taste buds dance with joy! The superb balance of fresh toppings and tangy tomato sauce created a heavenly marriage of flavors. I tried their pepperoni masterpiece, and let me tell you, each slice was a symphony of savory goodness. The crust was perfectly crispy while remaining soft in the center. With their welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, Donatos stands out as a must-visit for pizza lovers in Bexley. If you're craving a slice of joy, don't overlook this gem—it's simply slice-tastic! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Columbus.

East Pizzeria

At East Pizzeria, my taste buds danced with delight! Their Neapolitan-style pizza boasts a perfectly charred crust—crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside. The Margherita was a standout, featuring vibrant, fresh tomatoes and creamy mozzarella that melted harmoniously with every bite. The ambiance exudes a cozy charm, making it an ideal spot for a casual night out. I was also pleasantly surprised by their selection of local craft beers, which pair wonderfully with the pies. If you're on the hunt for pizza that balances tradition and flavor, East Pizzeria is certainly worth the visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.