The Absolute Best Ice Cream in Columbus [Updated 2025]

From the first lick of creamy vanilla to the last satisfying crunch of a cone, ice cream has always been my go-to treat. There’s something magical about that moment when your taste buds are whisked away by a rich swirl of flavor, and I can’t help but smile as I reminisce about my favorite ice cream adventures in this vibrant city.

After diving into the frosty delights of twelve top locations, I’m ready to share my sweet discoveries with you. Trust me, I’ve tasted everything from classic scoops to inventive flavors that push the boundaries of what ice cream can be. So, grab a spoon (or a cone!) and join me on this delicious journey through Columbus’s coolest ice cream spots!

Toft's Grand Scoop

Highlights
Friendly and patient staff
Delicious, varied flavors
Cozy atmosphere
Generous portion sizes
Unique topping options

Ah, Toft's Grand Scoop—a whimsical haven for ice cream enthusiasts nestled in the heart of Columbus! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a team of friendly and patient staff members, their smiles as welcoming as the enticing aromas of freshly crafted cones. The cozy atmosphere wrapped around me, making it the perfect spot to indulge my sweet tooth.

Now, let’s talk about the flavors! Toft's offers a delicious and varied selection that tantalizes the taste buds. I was particularly drawn to their signature flavors, including a rich Brownie Batter that was as decadent as it sounds. Each scoop was generously portioned, ensuring that every bite was a delightful experience. And oh, the toppings! The range of unique options allowed me to transform my treat into a personal masterpiece.

All in all, if you find yourself in Columbus and craving the best ice cream, look no further than Toft's Grand Scoop. With a perfect blend of tasty delights and an inviting vibe, it truly deserves a spot on your must-visit list. Go ahead, treat yourself—you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Little Ladies Soft Serve

Highlights
Unique toppings
Fun interior decorations
Diverse flavor options
Odd texture experience
Not traditional ice cream

Review of Little Ladies Soft Serve

During my exploration of Columbus’ ice cream scene, I stumbled upon Little Ladies Soft Serve, a delightfully quirky establishment that turned my expectations on their head. The playful interior decorations instantly enveloped me in a whimsical atmosphere that had me grinning from ear to ear.

What sets this place apart is their array of unique toppings. Imagine adding cotton candy or crumbled cookies to your soft serve! It’s like a childhood dream revisited in each scoop. Speaking of scoops, the flavors are diverse and innovative, making each visit an adventure for my taste buds. One moment I’m indulging in lavender vanilla, the next, I’m braving a dash of spicy chocolate.

While the soft serve offers a charming texture, it's certainly different from traditional ice cream. Think smooth but with a hint of whimsy—almost a little too airy for my liking, yet the novelty made it enjoyable.

In a city rich with frozen treats, Little Ladies Soft Serve stands out not just for its flavors but for the pure joy it brings to each visit. I left with a smile and already daydreaming about my next trip!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Dulce Vida Ice Cream Factory

Highlights
Vibrant decor and atmosphere
Delicious ice cream flavors
Outdoor patio available
Affordable pricing options
Popular spot during evenings

Dulce Vida Ice Cream Factory has quickly become one of my go-to spots in Columbus for a scoop of something sweet! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a vibrant decor that feels like a burst of happiness — perfect for treating your taste buds. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it easy to lose track of time while exploring their deliciously diverse flavors.

One of the most delightful aspects of my visit was the affordable pricing options. It’s always nice when you can indulge without breaking the bank! I chose to savor a scoop of their unique flavor, Mango Chili, a refreshing mix with just the right kick, leaving a playful dance of flavors on my palate.

The outdoor patio is a splendid place to enjoy your ice cream, especially during those warm Columbus evenings when the factory becomes a bustling hotspot. It’s no wonder this place has garnered affection among locals! Overall, my experience at Dulce Vida was nothing short of enchanting, and I can confidently say it deserves a spot among the best ice cream offerings in Columbus.

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Graeter's Ice Cream

Highlights
1930's nostalgic atmosphere
Polite and friendly staff
Tasty vegan options available
Quick service experience
Great for warm weather treats

Graeter's Ice Cream in Columbus is a delightful throwback to the 1930s, and stepping inside feels like entering a cozy, nostalgic charm that wraps around you like a warm hug. The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the polite and friendly staff, who seemed to genuinely relish the chance to help each customer. As I perused the extensive menu, I was thrilled to find that they offer tasty vegan options; it’s refreshing to see inclusivity in the ice cream world!

I decided to indulge in a scoop of their classic Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, and let me tell you, the flavors danced harmoniously on my palate. The rich chocolate chips made the experience even more delightful. What truly stood out was the quick service — just right for those hot, sun-kissed days when all you want is a frozen treat to cool you down.

Graeter's is not just about ice cream; it's about creating memories and enjoying a sweet treat with loved ones. If you're in Columbus and seeking a place that captures the essence of summertime indulgence, look no further than Graeter's!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Shake No Eight

Highlights
Cozy and Welcoming Atmosphere
Delicious Handmade Shakes
Friendly and Caring Staff
Great for Celebrations
Reasonable Prices

Shake No Eight is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, and let me tell you, it made my taste buds dance! As I stepped inside, the cozy and welcoming atmosphere drew me in instantly. It felt like a warm hug, a perfect backdrop for an afternoon of indulgence.

The menu boasts delicious handmade shakes, each one more tempting than the last. I opted for the classic chocolate shake, and I was not disappointed. The rich, creamy texture combined with the perfect amount of sweetness made it irresistible, leaving me wanting just one more sip.

What truly made the experience memorable was the friendly and caring staff. They were eager to share their recommendations and even offered to customize my shake upon request. Great customer service always enhances the ice cream experience!

Plus, it’s a fantastic spot for celebrations, with its vibrant energy and fantastic treats. As for pricing, I found it refreshingly reasonable, making it accessible for anyone looking to satisfy their sweet cravings.

All in all, Shake No Eight is a standout in the Columbus ice cream scene, and I can't wait to return for another delicious adventure!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Johnson's Real Ice Cream

Johnson's Real Ice Cream is a delightful gem that serves up nostalgia in every scoop! As I savored their signature flavors, each bite was a creamy explosion of genuine ingredients that danced upon my palate. The salted caramel was simply divine, striking the perfect balance between sweet and savory. With a charming atmosphere and friendly staff, it felt like a warm embrace on a sunny day. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic or an adventurous creation, Johnson's has you covered. I left with a smile, knowing I’d discovered yet another reason to love Columbus's ice cream scene!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams is an absolute delight that dances on the palate! With its creatively crafted flavors—like the enticing Honey Vanilla Bean and bold Goat Cheese with Fig—each scoop is a unique experience. The texture is luxuriously creamy, making every lick a little piece of heaven. The vibrant shop atmosphere envelops you in a warm, welcoming embrace, perfect for indulging your sweet tooth. I found myself torn between trying their seasonal offerings and the classic favorites! If you’re in Columbus and craving a scoop (or two), don’t miss out on this splendid gem that redefines ice cream perfection!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

Visiting Handel's Homemade Ice Cream in Columbus is like stepping into a delightful dream! Their Banana Cream Pie flavor is a luscious dance of creamy banana with hints of graham cracker, transporting you straight to summer picnics. I was equally enchanted by the rich texture of their Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, effortlessly blending nostalgia with a lavish twist. The welcoming staff adds to the experience, serving smiles alongside cones! If you're craving a scoop (or two) of pure joy, Handel’s should be at the top of your list—sweet satisfaction awaits you! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Columbus.

The Yard Milkshake Bar

At The Yard Milkshake Bar, I found an ice cream paradise that goes beyond the ordinary. Their towering creations are a feast for the eyes, combining playful flavors with whimsical toppings that spark joy. I indulged in the decadent “Brownie Batter”, a delight layered with rich chocolate goodness and crowned with whipped cream, sprinkles, and a mini brownie. The craftsmanship here is commendable; each milkshake is a delightful masterpiece. The atmosphere buzzes with energy, making it an ideal spot for both families and friends. For those seeking a sweet adventure, this is undoubtedly a must-visit in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.

Johnson’s Real Ice Cream

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, Johnson’s Real Ice Cream is a delightful haven for ice cream enthusiasts. With every scoop, their commitment to using premium ingredients shines through. The Peanut Butter Cup flavor was a heavenly blend of rich chocolate ice cream and creamy peanut butter, making each bite an indulgent treat. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for a cozy outing. Don’t miss the chance to try their seasonal specials, which never fail to surprise. Overall, Johnson's is a must-visit for anyone seeking truly artisanal ice cream in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

Diamonds Ice Cream

Stepping into Diamonds Ice Cream is like entering a whimsical wonderland of flavors! Their classic vanilla astounds with its creamy texture, while the salted caramel strikes a perfect balance between sweet and savory. I couldn’t resist trying their signature creations, especially the coconut mango swirl, which burst with tropical goodness. The cheerful staff adds to the charm, providing delightful recommendations that make the experience even better. With every scoop, I felt like a kid in a candy store, and I can't wait to return! For anyone craving sublime ice cream in Columbus, this gem is a must-visit!

Clown Cones & Confections

Stepping into Clown Cones & Confections feels like entering a whimsical treasure trove of flavors! Their signature Circus Peanut ice cream is a delightful twist that balances sweetness and nostalgia perfectly. The fun cone designs add a playful touch to the indulgence, making each scoop feel like a celebration. I was particularly impressed by their commitment to local ingredients, which enhances freshness in every bite. Service was friendly and infused with enthusiasm, reflecting the vibrant atmosphere. For those in search of a unique, cheerful ice cream experience, Clown Cones is a must-try in Columbus!