The Absolute Best Pizza Places in Hilliard

You want pizza in Hilliard, you’ve got options. Sure, you could stick with the same delivery chain, but then you’d miss the spot where a bowling lane fix comes with your slice, or the place that somehow makes Indian-Italian fusion work.

I’m talking about a town where a $15 tavern pie sits comfortably next to a NY-style slice with real snap, and where the best sausage might come from a low-key takeout counter. (Grandad’s never misses, by the way.

) I ate my way through all of it, twice, and left with a full stomach and a strong opinion. Here’s where you should be eating.

Ten Pin Pizza & More

Highlights
Bowling plus pizza combo
Generous lane problem fixes
Fun arcade while waiting
Great for private parties
Chill Tuesday night vibe

I walked in expecting bowling shoes and a greasy slice. What I got was way more. Ten Pin does the combo right. Pizza arrives hot while you're mid-frame. That's real service. My lane acted up once. Staff fixed it before I finished my soda. No drama. The arcade eats up downtime between games. Perfect for a birthday party or a Tuesday night when you need zero chaos. The vibe stays chill, even with kids running around. It's not gourmet pizza, but it doesn't need to be. It's fun on a plate with a side of strikes. I left full and relaxed. That's a win.

You might also want to check out the best views in Columbus.

Moon Pizza

Highlights
Unique Indian-Italian flavor mashup
Spicy pizza and calzones rock
Sauces and drippings steal show
Birthday-worthy colorful eats
Cravings killed, twice in week

Moon Pizza sounds odd on paper. Indian and Italian together? Trust me. It works. The spicy pies bring heat with a side of comfort. Calzones are stuffed and dangerous. The sauces steal every bite. I'm talking drippy, colorful, alive. I went twice in one week. That never happens. The birthday-worthy plates look festive enough for a party. Every craving I had got crushed. If you want predictable, go somewhere else. If you want a flavor mashup that actually makes sense, get to Moon. My taste buds are still buzzing. I need a nap.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Columbus.

Rubino's Pizza

Highlights
Old-school Italian favorite
Unique thick red sauce
Thin crust with crunch
Worth the parking trek

Rubino's is old school, and I mean that as a compliment. This place feels like your grandpa's favorite spot. The red sauce is thick and unique. It clings to the crust like it means it. And that crust? Thin with a serious crunch. Every bite sounds like joy. The parking lot is a trek, sure. You might circle a bit. But that's part of the charm. Once you're inside, it's all about the basics done right. No fuss, no gimmicks. Just solid Italian pizza that's been around for ages. Worth every step. I'd walk further for another slice.

You might also want to check out the best dispensary in Columbus.

Hillgarten Beer & Wine Garden

Highlights
Great drinks, inviting atmosphere
Dog-friendly with fire pits
Perfect for family fun
Worth the wait, awesome staff

Hillgarten isn't just about pizza. It's about the whole hang. The drinks are solid, and the vibe invites you to stay. They've got fire pits and a dog-friendly patio. My pup approved. The staff? Awesome. They stayed cool even when it got busy. We waited a bit, but it flew by. Families fit right in, and so do couples just relaxing. The pizza pairs perfectly with a cold one. This is the kind of place you stumble into and end up staying for hours. I'm already planning my next visit. Bring your dog and your patience. You'll thank me.

You might also want to check out the best malls in Columbus.

Terita's Pizza

Highlights
Homemade sausage steals show
Best pizza since moving
Low-key takeout spot
Worth the trip easily

Terita's is the low-key takeout spot I've been searching for. Since I moved to Hilliard, I've tried a bunch of places. This one wins. The homemade sausage is the star. It's juicy, seasoned just right, and makes every bite feel special. The pizza itself is simple and honest. No fuss, just quality. It's not fancy. That's the point. You call, you pick up, you eat. And you're happy. I'd drive across town for this. In fact, I might. The trip is worth it every time. If you haven't been, fix that. Your next pizza night is waiting.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in Columbus.

Crooked Can Brewing Co.

Highlights
Great beer, decent pizza
Fantastic seasonal stout selection
Warm, welcoming neighborhood vibe
Live music, good people
Unique premade cocktail bottles

Crooked Can nails the neighborhood brewery vibe. The beer is great, especially those seasonal stouts. Cozy. Dark. Perfect for cold evenings. The pizza is decent, not mind-blowing, but it pairs well with the taps. What really shines is the atmosphere. Warm, welcoming, full of good people. Live music hums in the background. You might even make a friend. They've got premade cocktail bottles that are surprisingly fun. Grab one to go. It's the kind of place where time slips away. You show up for one beer and leave three hours later. No regrets. Bring a jacket, grab a seat, and stay a while.

You might also want to check out the best shopping in Columbus.

Wilson's Bar & Grill

Highlights
Great food, fair prices
Friendly staff, relaxed vibe
Giant Wookie dessert wins
Crispy feta fries shine
Family friendly, never loud

Wilson's Bar & Grill does a lot right. The food is great and the prices are fair. That combo is rare. The staff? Friendly without being fake. The vibe stays relaxed, even when it's busy. A family can walk in and not feel awkward. That's a big plus. But let's talk about the giant Wookie dessert. It's absurd and wonderful. You'll want to take a photo first. Also, the crispy feta fries are a must. They're salty, crunchy, and addictive. I could eat those alone. The place never gets too loud, so you can actually talk. I left full and calm. That's the dream.

You might also want to check out the best companies to work for in Columbus.

Grandad's Pizza

Highlights
Never disappoints, ever
Great pizza size variety
Quick, friendly service
Tasty, interesting pies

Grandad's Pizza never misses. I've been a few times now, and every single visit is solid. The size variety helps. You can get a personal pie or feed a crowd. No stress either way. The service is quick and friendly. You don't wait long, even during rushes. The pies themselves are tasty and interesting. They're not afraid to try new combos. That keeps things exciting. I appreciate a place that respects tradition but adds a little flair. My last pie had a twist I didn't expect. It worked. If you want reliable and delicious, this is your spot. Grandad knows what he's doing.

You might also want to check out the best townhomes in Columbus.

Grandads Pizza and Pub

Highlights
Tavern-style pizza perfection
Friendly, attentive bartenders
$15 for a 16-inch pie
Easy seat-yourself vibe
Worth every stop back

The Pub version of Grandad's is a whole mood. Tavern-style pizza done right. Thin, crispy, and foldable. It's the perfect bar pie. I grabbed a 16-inch for just $15. That's a steal. The bartenders are attentive and know their regulars by name. The seat-yourself policy makes it easy. Walk in, find a spot, order. Done. The vibe is unpretentious and comfortable. I've stopped back multiple times now. Each visit reminds me why I keep coming. It's not fancy or flashy. It's just good pizza and good company. That's enough. Actually, that's everything.

You might also want to check out the best used car dealerships in Columbus.

Borgata Pizza Cafe

Highlights
Best NY-style pizza around
Fresh pasta and great toppings
Friendly staff, helpful service
Happy hour worth the trip
Killer meatball and pepper apps

Borgata is the real deal for NY-style pizza in Hilliard. The crust has that perfect chewy snap. Toppings are generous and fresh. They also do pasta, and it's legit. The happy hour is worth planning around. Cheap slices and drinks? Yes, please. The meatball and pepper apps are killers. I could make a meal of those alone and be happy. The staff is helpful, even when it's packed. They point you in the right direction. That matters. I've had a lot of so-called New York slices around here. Borgata is the closest to the real thing. Come hungry and leave happy. That's the promise.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Hilliard.

Grandma's Pizza on Parsons

Highlights
Best pizza in Columbus
Hot, delicious 10/10 pie
EZZO pepperoni is a win
Family-owned, quality ingredients
Gives back to local community

Grandma's Pizza on Parsons is the best pie in Columbus. I'll say it loud. The pizza arrives hot, cheesy, and perfect. I gave it a 10 out of 10, and I don't hand those out lightly. The EZZO pepperoni is a game changer. It cups up and gets crispy edges. Pure magic. This is a family-owned spot, and you can taste the care. Quality ingredients in every bite. They also give back to the community, which makes me feel better about my money. You're not just getting dinner. You're supporting good people. I already know my next order is coming soon. Grandma's got it.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artists in Columbus.

Forno Kitchen + Bar

Highlights
Great for big groups
Tasty American-style Italian
Crispy, juicy Chicken Marsala
Solid hotel staff recommendation

Forno is a solid pick when you're rolling deep. The menu is American-style Italian, and they pull it off well. I tried the Chicken Marsala, and it was crispy on the outside, juicy inside. That's a hard combo to nail. The sauce had real depth. The staff came through on a hotel recommendation, and they didn't steer me wrong. It's great for big groups because the seating is roomy and the service stays on point. Nothing fancy, but everything works. If you need a dependable meal with friends or family, this is it. I left full and satisfied. Mission accomplished.

You might also want to check out the best divorce lawyers in Columbus.