The Absolute Best Pizza in Hilliard [Updated 2025]

The smell of fresh dough rising, the sizzle of cheese melting to golden perfection—there’s nothing quite like the sensation of biting into a slice of pizza in our little corner of Ohio. Over countless weekends, late-night cravings, and even the occasional weekday lunch, I've traversed Hilliard's vibrant pizza landscape, sampling 12 top spots that promise not just a meal, but a slice of happiness.

As someone who’s savored every topping, crust, and sauce, I’ve developed a keen eye (and taste!) for what makes a pizza truly exceptional. Trust me, whether you're a classic cheese lover or adventurous enough to dive into gourmet creations, there's something here for everyone. Let’s dig into the flavors that make Hilliard a pizza paradise!

Moon Pizza

Highlights
Unique flavors and tastes
Best Indian pizza experience
Delicious garden and bullet pizza
Tasty special dipping sauces
Great for special occasions

Moon Pizza is a true gem tucked away in Hilliard, and my visit was a delightful adventure for my taste buds. As soon as I stepped inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza set the stage for an epic culinary experience. This is not your average pizza place; Moon Pizza prides itself on offering unique flavors that elevate the standard pie.

I opted for their Indian pizza, and let me tell you, it was an absolute revelation! The fusion of spices with traditional pizza ingredients was expertly crafted to create a taste sensation unlike any I've had before. The garden and bullet pizzas were equally impressive. Each slice was loaded with fresh toppings, bursting with vibrant flavors that danced on my palate.

Another highlight was their special dipping sauces—each one was more delicious than the last and perfectly complemented the pizza. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just indulging in a comforting meal, Moon Pizza is a fantastic choice. It’s clear this place is dedicated to pushing the boundaries of pizza. If you’re in Hilliard and craving something extraordinary, look no further than Moon Pizza! 🌙🍕

You might also want to check out the best views in Columbus.

Grandad's Pizza & Pub

Highlights
Great venue for live sports
Extensive menu options
Friendly and attentive service
Delicious garlic bread
Excellent Italian sub

Grandad's Pizza & Pub is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Hilliard. As soon as I stepped inside, the inviting atmosphere instantly caught my attention, especially with the live sports playing on multiple screens — perfect for any sports enthusiast.

The menu is impressively extensive, offering not just fabulous pizzas but also hearty Italian subs and a variety of appetizers. I opted for their signature pizza, and let me tell you, it was a true masterpiece! The crust was delightfully crispy, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful, perfectly harmonizing into each bite. To kick things off, I couldn't resist the garlic bread — a divine creation that left my taste buds begging for more.

What truly stood out during my visit was the friendly and attentive service. The staff were knowledgeable, recommending their favorite dishes and ensuring my dining experience was nothing short of stellar. Grandad's has successfully combined a laid-back vibe with top-notch food, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Hilliard. If you find yourself in the area, be sure to swing by — you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Columbus.

Ten Pin Pizza & More

Highlights
Free arcade card while waiting
Generous customer service
Great for private parties
Not overcrowded on Tuesday nights
Fantastic bowling experience

Ten Pin Pizza & More is a delightful gem tucked away in Hilliard, and my recent visit had me grinning from ear to ear! Upon walking in, I was greeted by warm, generous customer service that set the tone for what was to come. While waiting for my pizza—oh, the anticipation!—I was thrilled to receive a free arcade card, adding an extra sprinkle of fun to the experience.

I opted for a classic pepperoni pizza, and I must say, it hit all the right notes. The crust was perfectly crispy, while the mozzarella melted divinely, harmonizing with the zesty sauce beneath. Every bite danced on my palate, making it clear why locals rave about this spot.

And let’s not forget the ambiance! On a Tuesday night, the place wasn't overcrowded, allowing for a relaxing vibe as I savored my pie. Plus, Ten Pin offers a fantastic bowling experience, making it a superb choice for private parties or a casual outing with friends. Overall, Ten Pin Pizza & More delivers not just on flavor but on fun, making it one of the best pizza spots in Hilliard. I left with a full belly and a smile, eager to return!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artists in Columbus.

The O on Lane

Highlights
Excellent, friendly service
A+ delicious pepperoni pizza
Nice atmosphere and great vibe
Fast food service on game days
Fun, lively party atmosphere

The O on Lane is a gem that deserves a place on every pizza lover's radar. From the moment I stepped inside, the friendly service wrapped around me like a warm hug, instantly setting the tone for what was to come. The atmosphere is a delightful blend of fun and liveliness, perfect for both a casual dinner or a lively night out with friends.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the pepperoni pizza. The moment I took my first bite, I was greeted with a delightful dance of flavors. The cheese was perfectly melted, and the pepperoni was crispy and packed with that savory goodness that makes you crave more. I could practically hear my taste buds cheering in excitement!

On game days, the energy picks up as it fills with passionate fans, making it a great spot to gather for your favorite match while savoring a slice.

If you’re on the hunt for not just any pizza, but a delicious masterpiece that combines fantastic flavors with an inviting atmosphere, The O on Lane is undoubtedly one of the best options in Hilliard. You're in for a treat!

You might also want to check out the best bank in Columbus.

Mill Run Ale House

Upon entering Mill Run Ale House, I was greeted by a lively atmosphere that set the stage for a delightful pizza experience. I ordered their signature Pepperoni Pizza, which arrived with a perfectly crispy crust, a generous layer of zesty sauce, and an abundance of melty cheese. Each bite was a joyful explosion of flavors, accompanied by the lightest sprinkle of herbs. The ambiance and friendly service made the meal even sweeter. If you’re seeking a pizza that hits all the right notes, Mill Run Ale House is a must-try spot in Hilliard!

You might also want to check out the best casino in Columbus.

Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill in Hilliard is a delightful adventure for any pizza lover! Their signature crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, holding generously layered toppings without a hitch. I savored their BBQ Chicken Pizza, where tangy sauce complemented juicy chicken and zesty onions—simply mouthwatering! The atmosphere is vibrant, making it an ideal spot for families or a casual night out. Plus, their extensive beer selection elevates the experience. Whether dining in or taking out, you won’t regret indulging in this pizza paradise! If you're in Hilliard and craving a great slice, this place should be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best pumpkin patches in Columbus.

Halwani's Pizza & Stromboli - Hilliard Location

At Halwani's Pizza & Stromboli, I discovered a delightful slice of pizza paradise! The crust was perfectly crisp, with just the right balance of chewiness. I couldn't resist trying their signature Margherita, which boasted fresh basil and a savory sauce that danced on my taste buds. The toppings were generous, and their cheese? Melt-in-your-mouth perfection! The ambiance was warm, welcoming, and filled with the aroma of baked goodness. If you’re hunting for a pizza that combines quality and charm, Halwani's is definitely a must-try spot in Hilliard! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hiking in Columbus.

Luigi's Pizza

At Luigi's Pizza, the aroma hits you immediately, igniting a craving you didn't even know you had! I indulged in their signature Margherita pizza, where the fresh basil danced beautifully atop the golden mozzarella. Each bite was an explosion of flavor, perfectly balanced and utterly delightful. The crispy crust was a standout, giving that satisfying crunch I adore. What truly impressed me was the warm and inviting atmosphere; it felt like a slice of Italy right in Hilliard. For anyone in search of a culinary adventure, I highly recommend giving Luigi's a try! 🍕 You won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best realtors in Columbus.

Ange's Pizza Hilliard

Ange’s Pizza Hilliard is a delightful gem that transforms the pizza experience into a culinary adventure! The moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me. I chose the classic pepperoni, and with each bite, the crispy crust and zesty sauce danced on my palate, creating an irresistible harmony of flavors. Their generous cheese stretch is a sight to behold! The service was friendly and attentive, making me feel right at home. If you’re on a quest for the best pizza in Hilliard, Ange’s is a must-visit destination that will surely satisfy your cravings!

Sexton’s Pizza

Sexton’s Pizza in Hilliard is a delightful discovery! The thin crust achieves that perfect crunch, while the generous portion of cheese melts beautifully, creating an irresistible combination. Topped with a zesty sauce that has just the right amount of kick, each bite bursts with flavor. I highly recommend the pepperoni—it's a classic done right! The cozy atmosphere makes it a great spot for family gatherings or a casual night out. Overall, Sexton’s is a must-try for any pizza enthusiast looking to satisfy their cravings. My taste buds are already calling for a second round! 🍕

Flyers Pizza Hilliard

At Flyers Pizza Hilliard, each bite is a true celebration of flavors. The crust is perfectly crispy, delivering that satisfying crunch while holding a robust array of toppings. I opted for their signature Flyers Special, which boasted a delightful blend of fresh veggies and savory meats that danced on my palate. Every slice was generously loaded, ensuring I never felt shortchanged. The ambiance is casual yet inviting—perfect for a night out or a cozy take-home feast. Overall, if you're after pizza that blends quality and taste effortlessly, Flyers deserves a prominent place on your pizza radar!

Flyers Pizza Hayden Run

During my visit to Flyers Pizza Hayden Run, I discovered an unexpected haven for pizza lovers in Hilliard. The crust had just the right amount of crispness, and the generous toppings were a delightful explosion of flavors. I devoured their signature flyer pie, topped with fresh ingredients that boasted quality. What truly set this place apart was the cozy, laid-back atmosphere, perfect for a casual night out. If you're on the hunt for a pizza experience that balances quality and comfort, look no further than Flyers Pizza—a gem indeed! 🍕