The Absolute Best Seafood Market in Columbus [Updated 2025]

Picture this: the salty breeze on my face as I stroll through bustling aisles, the vibrant colors of fresh fish glistening under the market lights, and the tantalizing aroma of spices wafting through the air. I’ve spent countless weekends exploring eight of Columbus's top seafood markets, diving deep into their offerings and soaking up the local flavors. From succulent shrimp to plump scallops, each place tells a story, and I can’t wait to share what I’ve discovered.

As someone who’s spent years perfecting my seafood skills in the kitchen, I’ve developed a keen eye for quality. You can trust my insights, because I’ve tasted, tested, and compared each market’s offerings to find the crème de la crème. Get ready to embark on a delicious journey through Columbus’s seafood treasures!

COLO Market & Oyster Bar Downtown

Highlights
Great quality seafood
Variety of oyster dishes
Limited seating but welcoming
Happy hour oyster pricing
Amazing first-time experience

When I stepped into COLO Market & Oyster Bar Downtown, I was immediately greeted by the fresh scent of the sea, a telltale sign of quality seafood. The display of fresh catches was enticing—each item practically whispered recipes to me. I couldn't resist indulging in their variety of oyster dishes, and let me tell you, they did not disappoint! The sweet and briny flavor of each oyster lingered deliciously, and with their happy hour pricing, I felt like I hit the jackpot.

While the seating is limited, the atmosphere is incredibly welcoming, fostering a sense of community among seafood lovers. I felt right at home as I savored my selections. As a first-time visitor, my experience was nothing short of delightful. I found myself laughing and chatting over the delightful ambiance.

COLO Market is not just a seafood market; it’s a vibrant experience. It's the kind of place where every meal can become a joyful adventure. If you're in search of fresh seafood that shines in quality and taste, look no further! COLO Market & Oyster Bar Downtown is a must-visit for anyone in Columbus craving that ultimate seafood experience!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Columbus Fish & Seafood Wholesale

Highlights
Excellent food quality
Attentive and helpful staff
Closed since 2022
Lack of website updates

Columbus Fish & Seafood Wholesale is a hidden gem that absolutely deserves a spotlight, even if it sat closed since 2022. Walking into the shop, I was immediately drawn in by the irresistible aroma of fresh seafood that wafted through the air, promising treasures from the ocean. The display was a depiction of quality; shimmering fish, succulent shrimp, and a delightful array of shellfish greeted me like old friends.

The staff here is both attentive and knowledgeable, eager to share their expertise and help you select the perfect catch for your next dish. Even during my visit, when I could see they were under pressure, they maintained a level of service that felt incredibly personal.

While sadly there's a lack of updates on their website, if you find yourself in Columbus, it’s worth stopping by to see what's fresh and available. I can't wait for them to reopen so I can indulge in more of their fantastic offerings! If you’re a seafood lover and find yourself in the area, consider Columbus Fish & Seafood Wholesale a bucket-list destination—your palate will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

COLO Market & Oyster Bar Dublin

Highlights
Fantastic fresh oysters
Delicious lobster rolls
Tasty clam chowder
Located near Bridge Park
Trustworthy raw oyster consumption

COLO Market & Oyster Bar Dublin has truly captured my seafood-loving heart! Nestled conveniently near Bridge Park, this bustling gem is not just an oyster bar; it’s a haven for seafood enthusiasts. As I stepped inside, the aromatic allure of fresh seafood immediately beckoned me.

One cannot miss their fantastic fresh oysters, which are perhaps the stars of the show. I indulged in a few, and let me tell you, each bite was a delightful burst of the ocean—so fresh that it felt like they were plucked moments ago! For those who prefer something a bit more substantial, their delicious lobster rolls are a must-try; overflowing with succulent lobster meat, they strike a perfect balance of richness and flavor.

I also indulged in their tasty clam chowder. Creamy with just the right hint of seasoning, it was the ideal comfort food to pair with my seafood feast. Every element at COLO radiates trustworthiness, especially when it comes to raw oyster consumption.

In sum, COLO Market & Oyster Bar Dublin stands out in Columbus’ seafood market scene, delivering quality and experience in every bite. It’s a destination you shouldn't overlook!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Frank's Fish And Seafood Market

Stepping into Frank's Fish And Seafood Market feels like a joyful dive into the ocean without leaving Columbus! Their selection is nothing short of impressive, featuring everything from fresh shrimp to flaky white fish, all displayed with care. The staff is not only knowledgeable but radiate a friendly vibe, ready to help you make the perfect selection. I couldn’t resist the deliciously crafted seafood tacos they had on offer—a must-try! With its vibrant atmosphere and dedication to quality, Frank's has certainly secured its place as one of the best seafood markets in town. You won't leave empty-handed!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Weiland's Market

During my visit to Weiland's Market, I was immediately struck by the impeccable freshness of their seafood selection. The crisp aroma wafting from the counters hinted at a bounty straight from the ocean. Their knowledgeable staff eagerly shared insider tips on preparation and pairing, making the experience enlightening and enjoyable. The selection of wild-caught options showcases their commitment to quality, and the sanitary layout adds to the charm of this neighborhood gem. With a cozy atmosphere, Weiland's is truly a delightful stop for both the seafood enthusiast and casual cook alike!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Columbus Fish Market

Stepping into Columbus Fish Market felt like entering seafood paradise! The freshness of their catch is simply unparalleled; I couldn’t resist the temptation of vibrant salmon and succulent scallops. The knowledgeable staff eagerly guided me through their seasonal selections, embodying passion for sustainable fishing practices. I was particularly impressed by the daily specials, showcasing local favorites. The market exudes a friendly, bustling atmosphere that invites even the most novice cooks to create delectable seafood dishes. If you’re seeking quality and variety, this gem is undoubtedly a must-visit for seafood lovers in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Tensuke Market, llc

Stepping into Tensuke Market feels like entering a hidden gem of the culinary world! The freshness of their seafood is undeniable, with an impressive variety that includes everything from shimmering sashimi to plump shrimp. The atmosphere buzzes with a delightful energy, and the staff is always ready with a smile and expert advice. I was particularly enchanted by the selection of exotic catches, which ignited my inner chef with inspiration. Whether you're a seafood novice or a seasoned cook, Tensuke offers an inviting experience sure to delight your palate. Don’t miss out on this oceanic treasure in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

Southeast Fish & Produce

Southeast Fish & Produce is truly a hidden gem in the heart of Columbus! From the moment I walked in, the freshness of the seafood was evident. The vibrantly displayed fish and shellfish practically danced off the ice, showcasing their quality. I appreciated the knowledgeable staff, who were more than eager to share cooking tips and recipe ideas. Plus, the addition of local produce made this market feel like a community hub. If you’re looking for an exceptional seafood selection combined with a warm atmosphere, you simply must visit Southeast Fish & Produce. Deliciously recommended!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.