The Absolute Best Restaurants in Bexley [Updated 2025]

The moment you step into those charming little eateries in Bexley, the tantalizing aromas wrap around you like a cozy blanket. I still remember my first bite of homemade pasta at that quaint Italian spot—each forkful was a little piece of heaven that danced on my taste buds. After countless meals, late-night tastings, and whispered conversations with passionate chefs, I’ve narrowed it down to 12 top locations that showcase the heart and soul of this vibrant community.

You can trust my expertise because I’ve savored every bite, scrutinized every plate, and soaked in the atmosphere of each restaurant. Whether you’re craving comfort food or a culinary adventure, I’m here to guide you through the flavors that make Bexley a true dining destination. Let’s dig in!

Brassica in Bexley

Highlights
Healthy and delicious meals
Friendly and attentive staff
Clean and inviting atmosphere
Excellent food quality
Great value for money

Brassica in Bexley truly exceeded my expectations with its vibrant atmosphere and commitment to healthy dining. As soon as I walked through the door, I was greeted by the friendly staff, whose attentiveness made me feel right at home. The clean and inviting ambiance perfectly set the stage for what was to come.

The menu at Brassica boasts an array of healthy yet scrumptious offerings that cater to various tastes. I indulged in a seasonal salad that was bursting with freshness and flavor—each ingredient felt thoughtfully chosen. To top it off, the presentation was nothing short of stunning, making the dish as much a feast for the eyes as it was for the palate.

What impressed me most was the exceptional food quality coupled with great value for money. In today's culinary landscape, finding a place that balances health, taste, and affordability is no small feat.

In a bustling locale like Bexley, Brassica stands out as a must-visit destination for those seeking a delightful dining experience. If you’re in the area and craving something healthy and delicious, Brassica is calling your name!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

Highlights
Excellent fried pickles
Cooked-to-perfection burgers
Quick and friendly service
Clean and family-friendly
Tasty chicken Parmesan

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern in Bexley is a delightful gem that brings the warmth of a neighborhood pub with a twist of culinary flair. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the delightful aroma that instantly set my stomach rumbling. I couldn't resist starting my meal with their excellent fried pickles—a crunchy, tangy delight that pairs perfectly with their signature dipping sauce.

Moving on to the main course, I opted for a burger cooked to perfection. Every bite was juicy and packed with flavor, proving that they take their craft seriously. For those not in a burger mood, I highly recommend the tasty chicken Parmesan; it’s a winning choice that showcases the kitchen’s ability to deliver comfort food with finesse.

What truly stands out at Rusty Bucket is the quick and friendly service—my server was attentive without being intrusive, making me feel right at home. The atmosphere was clean and inviting, perfect for a family outing or a casual evening with friends. It's safe to say that Rusty Bucket is one of my top picks in Bexley, offering a satisfying dining experience that will keep you coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.

The Top Steak House

Highlights
Old school steakhouse vibe
Live piano music ambiance
Oysters Rockefeller standout
Excellent filet mignon
Comfortable booth seating

The Top Steak House in Bexley exudes an inviting old-school steakhouse vibe that instantly transports you to an era of refined dining. As I stepped inside, the soft strains of live piano music wrapped around me like a well-tailored jacket, setting the perfect backdrop for a culinary adventure.

Diving into the menu, I couldn't resist starting with their standout Oysters Rockefeller, which were succulent and packed with flavor—a delightful introduction to the offerings here. But the pièce de résistance was undoubtedly the filet mignon. Cooked to impeccable perfection, it melted in my mouth and left me wishing for a second round. The comfortable booth seating added to the relaxed atmosphere, making it an ideal setting for a special occasion or just a treat-yourself night out.

Every bite I savored was complemented by the attentive and friendly staff, enhancing the overall experience. The ambiance, food, and service all blended seamlessly to create a memorable evening. If you’re looking to indulge your senses and enjoy a night of culinary delight, The Top Steak House has earned its place at the top of my list for the best restaurants in Bexley.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

Newfangled Kitchen

During my delightful visit to Newfangled Kitchen, I was charmed by its vibrant atmosphere and innovative menu. Each dish, a whimsical twist on classic comfort food, was a storytelling adventure for the palate. My taste buds danced with joy as I indulged in their famous brisket tacos, bursting with flavor and creativity. The friendly staff added to the warm ambiance, making me feel right at home. Don’t forget to save room for their decadent desserts—each bite is a sweet revelation. If you’re in Bexley, this gem is a must-try for those who crave culinary creativity and comfort in every bite!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Upper Arlington.

Giuseppe's Ritrovo

At Giuseppe's Ritrovo, I discovered a delightful slice of Italy right in the heart of Bexley. The atmosphere buzzes with warmth, perfect for a cozy dinner or a festive gathering. I absolutely adored the house-made pasta, which was al dente perfection, and their signature marinara sauce was a taste of heaven. The staff were not only attentive but also radiated a genuine passion for their menu. For dessert, the tiramisu stole my heart—light, creamy, and just the right amount of coffee kick! If you're seeking an authentic Italian experience, Giuseppe's is a must-visit gem in Bexley!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Circleville.

Stav's Diner

At Stav's Diner, I felt like I’d stepped into a cozy time capsule, brimming with charm and nostalgic vibes. The classic diner fare was elevated with a twist, especially the homemade burgers and spectacular milkshakes* that practically danced off the menu. The staff exuded warmth and friendliness, creating an inviting atmosphere that made me want to linger. I particularly loved the cheerful décor, which adds a delightful touch to the whole dining experience. If you're on the hunt for comfort food served with a smile, Stav's Diner in Bexley is definitely worth a visit! 🍔✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Gahanna.

Harvest Pizzeria Bexley

Harvest Pizzeria Bexley is a delightful culinary gem that artfully combines comfort and creativity. The moment I stepped inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough wrapped around me like a warm hug. Their artisan pizzas boast a crust that is both crispy and chewy, drizzled with vibrant sauces and topped with local ingredients that sing of quality. I couldn't resist trying the seasonal special, which burst with flavors that danced on my taste buds. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal. If you're in Bexley, don't miss out on this pizza paradise!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Hilliard.

Scotty's Cafe

Scotty's Cafe in Bexley is a delightful gem that whisks you away to a cozy, comforting embrace with every visit. The charming ambiance is matched only by their menu, which boasts hearty portions and mouthwatering flavors. I savored their famous breakfast burrito, bursting with fresh ingredients and a zesty kick. The staff exude warmth and friendliness, making you feel like part of the family. Don't forget to indulge in their homemade pastries—each bite is a little piece of heaven! If you're searching for a friendly spot that serves up delicious food, Scotty's Cafe should be your next stop!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Canal Winchester.

Khaab Indian Kitchen & Bar

My visit to Khaab Indian Kitchen & Bar was a delightful tapestry of flavors! The moment I stepped in, the warm ambiance wrapped around me like a cozy shawl. I savored a bowl of their rich butter chicken, which danced on my palate with its perfect blend of spices. The naan was a fluffy cloud, ideal for mopping up every last drop. The service was as attentive as the spices were vibrant—truly a symphony of experiences! If you're seeking a taste of India in Bexley, this gem is an absolute must-visit for an unforgettable culinary adventure.

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in Columbus.

Cafe Istanbul Bexley

Tucked away in the heart of Bexley, Cafe Istanbul is a delightful gem that whisks you straight to Turkey with its vibrant atmosphere and mouthwatering dishes. Upon entering, the inviting aroma of spices enveloped me, setting the stage for a feast. I savored the lamb kofta, which was tender and bursting with flavor, while the mezze platter was a colorful dance of textures and tastes. The hospitality was warm and genuine, making the experience even more memorable. If you’re looking to indulge in a unique culinary adventure, Cafe Istanbul is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in Columbus.

Noahla

I recently dined at Noahla, a culinary gem in Bexley that delighted my taste buds from the moment I stepped in. The atmosphere is a perfect blend of charm and sophistication, making it ideal for any occasion. I savored their signature dishes, particularly the grilled octopus, which was tender and perfectly seasoned. The staff were not only attentive but also conveyed an infectious passion for their menu. With an array of delightful flavors and an inviting ambiance, Noahla is certainly a must-visit for anyone seeking an unforgettable dining adventure in Bexley!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Piada Italian Street Food

In the heart of Bexley, Piada Italian Street Food captivates with its vibrant atmosphere and delightful flavors. The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of fresh ingredients. I savored the signature piada—thin, savory Italian flatbreads filled with a dazzling array of ingredients. Each bite was a dance of textures and tastes! The staff exuded warmth, enhancing the inviting ambiance. If you're in the mood for a quick yet satisfying meal, Piada is your go-to gem. With its authentic offerings and friendly service, this spot is sure to make your taste buds sing!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.