The Absolute Best Restaurant in Ashville

Ashville’s food map is a mess in the best way. You can grab a flawless buckeye protein coffee at Lisa’s Sweet Shoppe, then hit Jackie Ray’s for a BBQ-loaded western burger, all without leaving town.

But the place also serves up a Subway with hair in the food and a Fork in Nigeria that fumbles spice execution. We ate through the diner omelets, the winery tasting room, and the sticky-floored pizza joints to sort the keepers from the skips.

One thing’s certain: the pulled pork nachos at City Barbeque beat anything within twenty miles. Here’s where your next meal should land.

Cherry Street Diner

Highlights
Friendly service, fair prices
Great omelets, outstanding fries
Multigeneration family diner
Fully stocked morning salad bar
Straightforward, solid menu

I walked into Cherry Street Diner and felt like I'd stepped into someone's Sunday kitchen. The staff greeted me like a regular, even on my first visit. Prices are fair, and the menu is straightforward and solid. My omelet came out fluffy and packed with fillings. The fries were the real standout, crisp and salty. A fully stocked morning salad bar sits ready for early risers. It's a multigeneration family place, and that warmth shows. No surprises here, just dependable food and friendly service. That's worth something. I left full and satisfied.

I'll be back for those fries.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

City Barbeque

Highlights
Dog-friendly covered patio
Top-notch pulled pork nachos
Juicy, flavorful Bama chicken
Excellent sweet tea selection
Friendly staff, clean space

City Barbeque knows how to handle meat. I tried the Bama chicken first, and it was juicy and packed with flavor. The pulled pork nachos deserve top billing, loaded and messy in the best way. Sweet tea options are excellent, and the staff kept things friendly and the space clean. They even have a dog-friendly covered patio, which is a nice touch for warmer days. Everything felt efficient and welcoming. I didn't wait long for my order. The barbecue holds up, and the sides round things out nicely. A solid stop for a quick, satisfying meal in Ashville.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Westerville.

Fork in Nigeria

Highlights
Inconsistent food quality
Portion sizes mismatched
Sketchy building conditions
Poor spice execution
Thin onion additions

Fork in Nigeria sounded promising. It wasn't. The food quality came out inconsistent, with some dishes arriving lukewarm and others bland. Portion sizes felt mismatched, leaving me either overstuffed or still hungry. The building conditions are sketchy, which never helps the appetite. Spice execution missed the mark, too much heat in some bites, none in others. Even the onions seemed thin and apologetic. I wanted to like it. The concept has potential, but the execution falls short. I left disappointed. There are better options in Ashville. I won't be rushing back.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Grove City.

Pizza Cottage

Highlights
Pizza earns high marks
Fried pickles steal show
Online pickup runs smoothly
Staff polite and friendly
Heavy metal, sticky floors

Pizza Cottage has a strange charm. The pizza earns high marks, with a solid crust and generous cheese. But the fried pickles steal the show, crispy and tangy. Online pickup runs smoothly, and the staff are polite and friendly. The atmosphere is a hard read, heavy metal playing, sticky floors underfoot. It's not a place for a quiet dinner. But if you want good pizza and a vibe that doesn't care, it works. The contrast is part of the fun. I grabbed my order, dodged a few spills, and headed out. I'll be back for those pickles.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Worthington.

Subway

Highlights
Fast, not fresh.
Hair found, appetite lost.
Rude owners, wrong bread.
Policy ignored, arguments ensue.
Skip this Subway.

Skip this Subway. Fast, but not fresh. I found a hair in my food, and that was it for me. The owners were rude when I mentioned it, arguing policy instead of apologizing. They gave me the wrong bread and wouldn't fix it. The whole experience left a bad taste. I understand mistakes happen, but the response matters. This location ignored basic courtesy. I left without my appetite. There are better sandwich spots nearby. Save yourself the frustration. Go somewhere else.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in New Albany.

Jackie Ray's Grill

Highlights
Sweet tea is fantastic
Jalapeño poppers pleasantly surprising
Comfortable modern-rustic interior
Clean restroom with mints
Generous BBQ on western burger

Jackie Ray's Grill delivers on comfort. The sweet tea is fantastic, sweet enough to remind you of summer. I tried the jalapeño poppers and they surprised me, creamy with a real kick. The interior sits somewhere between modern and rustic, with wood and metal working together. The restroom was clean, and they even had mints by the sink. Nice touch. The western burger came loaded with BBQ and generous portions. Everything tasted fresh and handled with care. Service was friendly and quick. I left full and happy. This place earns its spot on the list.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.

Ashbrook Grill

Highlights
Wings, fries, cheese sticks
Kids love mozzarella sticks
Pool table available
Good food, friendly service
Worth a repeat visit

Ashbrook Grill does simple things right. Wings, fries, cheese sticks, all solid. The mozzarella sticks are a hit with kids, and mine asked for more. They have a pool table, which adds a fun layer to the evening. Food came out hot, and the service was friendly throughout. It's not a fancy place, but it doesn't need to be. Good food and a welcoming atmosphere make it an easy choice. We packed up satisfied and already planning a return visit. For a casual meal, this works. I'll be back.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

River's Coffee House

Highlights
Killer chai and curry rice
Maple bacon earns devotion
Vanilla apple fritter fantastic
Kids love the donuts
Worth a Michigan pit stop

River's Coffee House is a great stop. The chai is killer, spicy and smooth. I also had the curry rice, which was surprisingly good for a coffee shop. The maple bacon deserves its devotion, sweet and savory in perfect balance. My vanilla apple fritter was fantastic, flaky and warm. Kids love the donuts, and mine cleaned their plates. Prices are fair and the place feels cozy. It's worth a Michigan pit stop, even if you're just passing through. I left caffeinated and full. This is a hidden stop, but not for me. It's now a regular.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Upper Arlington.

Kelli Jo's

Highlights
Cheap eats, generous portions
Wings rival Roosters' quality
Bingo night wins families over
Friendly staff, professional service
Under $60 for two, stuffed

Kelli Jo's offers serious value. I got two meals under $60 and left stuffed. The wings rival Roosters' quality, meaty and saucy. Bingo night brought in families and we joined in. The staff are friendly and professional, handling a busy room with ease. Portions are generous, and the prices are low. Nothing felt rushed or cheap. I ate too much and regretted nothing. This is a local spot that delivers. If you want good food without the fuss, this is your place. I'll bring the whole family next time.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Circleville.

Mirabelle Farm & Vineyard

Highlights
Warm, family-owned winery
Quality over quantity wines
Owners personally connect guests
Family-friendly, thoughtful amenities
Cozy tasting room with games

Mirabelle Farm & Vineyard is a warm, family-owned winery. The owners personally connected with us, asking about our day and our tastes. They focus on quality over quantity, and it shows in every glass. The tasting room is cozy, with games on hand for families. Kids can play while adults sip. It's thoughtful and welcoming. I tried several wines and found each one balanced. The setting feels personal, not commercial. This is a place to slow down. I left with a bottle and a good feeling. A lovely stop in Ashville.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Gahanna.

Off The Rails

Highlights
Cleaned up, solid pies
Brad's masterful pizzas
Friendly bartenders Rachel, Heather
Dive bar warmth, welcoming
Great pizza, easy vibe

Off The Rails surprised me. I expected a dive bar and found one, but it's been cleaned up nicely. The pizza is seriously good. Brad's pies are masterful, with a crust that holds up to generous toppings. Bartenders Rachel and Heather kept things friendly and quick. The vibe is easy and welcoming, like a neighborhood spot that knows its regulars. I sat at the bar, ate a slice, and felt at home. It's not fancy, but it doesn't try to be. If you want solid pizza without pretension, this is your place. I'll be back for another round and a pie.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Hilliard.

Lisa's Sweet Shoppe

Highlights
Buckeye protein coffee wins
Historic building, friendly staff
Extensive sweets and ice cream
Reasonable prices, welcoming vibe
Ideal stop to beat heat

Lisa's Sweet Shoppe is a lovely pit stop. The buckeye protein coffee is a genius combo, and it hit the spot after a long drive. The building has history, and the staff are warm and chatty. They have an extensive selection of sweets and ice cream, all at reasonable prices. My vanilla apple fritter was fantastic, buttery and soft. It's the ideal spot to beat the heat. I grabbed a few treats to go. The welcoming vibe makes you want to linger. I left with a full bag and a lighter mood. Worth the detour.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Chillicothe MO.