Zanesville's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

As I sank my teeth into a slice of hot, cheesy bliss, the tangy aroma of fresh tomato sauce wafted through the air, and I was instantly transported to pizza paradise. Zanesville, with its charming streets and welcoming vibe, has some hidden gems that truly deserve the spotlight—after sampling 12 top locations, I can confidently say that this town knows how to do pizza right.

Trust me, I've put in the research, taste-testing every crust, sauce, and topping combination you can imagine. Whether you crave a classic margherita or something a little more adventurous, I’m here to guide you through the savory delights that Zanesville has to offer. Get ready to find your new favorite slice!

Pizza Cottage

Highlights
Friendly and great service
Beautifully presented food
Overpriced for lunch
Inconsistent food quality
Issues with order accuracy

Pizza Cottage in Zanesville is a charming spot that offers a delightful escape for pizza enthusiasts. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by their friendly staff, making me feel right at home. The ambiance is warm, perfect for a casual meal with friends or family.

One aspect that stands out is their beautifully presented food. Each pizza looks like a mouthwatering work of art, topped with fresh ingredients that almost make you hesitant to dig in—almost! However, while the pizzas are visually appealing, I found the food quality to be inconsistent. On my visit, I was left wondering if I had ordered the wrong pie or if the culinary magic just didn’t happen that day.

Another consideration when dining at Pizza Cottage is the pricing. It felt a bit steep for lunch, which made me rethink my choices. Additionally, I experienced some frustrations with order accuracy—important when you’re starving for a slice!

Overall, while Pizza Cottage has its ups and downs, its friendly service and gorgeous presentations make it a noteworthy place to indulge in pizza. Just be aware that experience may vary!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Creno's Pizza Zanesville | Maple Ave

Highlights
Great pizza and pasta
Excellent service
Small seating area
Uncomfortable counter stools
Inconsistent sub quality

As I walked into Creno's Pizza Zanesville, I was greeted by the heavenly aroma of freshly baked pizza, instantly setting the stage for a delightful meal. While the small seating area may give it a quaint atmosphere, it made the experience feel intimate—almost like I was dining in a friend’s kitchen. Though the counter stools left a little to be desired in the comfort department, I easily overlooked that when the excellent service kicked in.

I decided to indulge in a classic pepperoni pizza, and let me tell you, it was a slice of perfection! The crust was perfectly crispy, and the toppings were generous without being overwhelming. The great pizza and pasta choices keep customers coming back for more, and I can see why. However, I must mention that I noticed some inconsistent sub quality during a previous visit, but the pizza more than made up for it this time around.

Overall, my trip to Creno's was a delightful experience, and I highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area. Prepare yourself for a slice that truly captures the heart of Zanesville pizza culture!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Creno's Pizza East

Highlights
Fast and friendly service
Enjoyable food quality
Popular salad options
Kids love the flat bread
Variety of menu items

Creno’s Pizza East is a delightful gem that does not disappoint! Upon stepping through the doors, I was met with fast and friendly service—a warm welcome that set the tone for my visit. I couldn’t resist trying their signature pizza, and wow, it exceeded all expectations. The enjoyable food quality really brings a smile to your face with each cheesy bite.

One of the stars of the show was their flatbread, which my kids absolutely adored. It’s not just pizza here; there’s a variety of menu items that cater to everyone’s palate, including some delicious salad options that are surprisingly popular. Despite being a pizza joint, Creno's proves that it’s important to keep things fresh and vibrant.

I appreciate that they strike the perfect balance between classic flavors and creativity, making it a wonderful spot for families or a fun night out with friends. If you’re seeking delicious pizza in Zanesville, look no further than Creno’s. It’s a slice of heaven that truly encapsulates the spirit of pizza perfection.

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

A Taste of Ohio, Wine, Bourbon & Beer

Highlights
Incredible food
Warm and welcoming atmosphere
Top-notch drink selection
Attentive and kind staff
Clean and relaxing environment

A Taste of Ohio, Wine, Bourbon & Beer is a delightful gem tucked away in Zanesville that truly elevates the pizza experience. Upon entering, I was immediately embraced by a warm and welcoming atmosphere that invited me to relax and indulge. The first element that struck me was the incredible food—a testament to how pizza should be crafted! Each slice boasted a perfectly crispy crust topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

One bite of their signature pie and I was transported to a culinary paradise where flavors melded beautifully. But what truly set this place apart was not just the pizza; it was the top-notch drink selection that complemented my meal perfectly. From local wines to a curated bourbon list, my taste buds were in for a treat.

The attentive and kind staff made my dining experience all the more enjoyable, ensuring I was well taken care of throughout my visit. Plus, the clean and relaxing environment added to the delightful ambiance.

If you find yourself in Zanesville, I wholeheartedly recommend heading to A Taste of Ohio. Whether you’re indulging in pizza or exploring their drink offerings, this place promises a memorable culinary adventure!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Russo's Kitchen + Bar

At Russo's Kitchen + Bar, the atmosphere is as inviting as their mouthwatering pizza selection. I indulged in their signature Margherita pie, which boasted a flaky crust, topped with vibrant tomatoes and fresh basil. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors, perfectly balanced by the rich mozzarella. The charming staff added to the experience, making me feel right at home. If you're seeking a slice of culinary heaven, Russo’s is a place you shouldn't miss—it's a true gem in Zanesville's pizza landscape! Deliciousness guaranteed!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Tat's Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped into Tat's Pizzeria, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me, welcoming me like an old friend. Their signature pies, with a perfect balance of crispy crust and zesty sauce, left my taste buds dancing. I couldn’t resist the meat lovers’ delight, piled high with quality toppings that felt both indulgent and comforting. The friendly staff added a touch of warmth to the already inviting atmosphere. For anyone seeking a delicious slice in Zanesville, Tat’s is a must-visit, where every bite is a delightful reminder of why we love pizza. 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Adornetto's Pizzeria

At Adornetto's Pizzeria, I found a delightful blend of tradition and flavor. The thin crust was perfectly crispy, cradling generous toppings that burst with freshness. Their signature Margherita pizza showcased a beautiful harmony of basil, mozzarella, and tangy tomato sauce—pure pizza bliss! The cozy atmosphere made it a perfect spot to savor every bite. The staff demonstrated incredible hospitality, enhancing the overall experience that felt like a warm hug. If you’re searching for pizza that balances crunch and comfort, Adornetto's is a must-visit gem in Zanesville, leaving me eager for my next slice of happiness!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

The Barn

With its charming atmosphere and rustic decor, The Barn serves up pizzas that feel like a warm hug on a plate. I indulged in their signature Barnstormer pizza, topped with a perfect balance of fresh ingredients and zesty sauce. The crust was delightfully crispy, yet soft enough to fold — just how I like it! What truly sets this place apart is the generous portion of toppings, which were bursting with flavor. When it comes to pizza in Zanesville, The Barn truly raises the bar. In a town full of options, this gem is definitely worth a visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Maxwell's Drive-thru & Pizzeria | Zanesville, OH

From the moment I pulled up to Maxwell's Drive-thru & Pizzeria, the delightful aroma of fresh pizza enveloped me. I opted for their signature pepperoni pizza, and let me tell you—it exceeded all expectations! The crust was perfectly golden and crispy, while the marinara was robust yet smooth. Each slice showcased ample cheese and generous, quality toppings that made every bite an adventure. The quirky drive-thru setup added a fun twist, making pizza night feel special, even on a whim. If you're in Zanesville, don’t miss out on what might be the best slice in town!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Columbus.

Lucky's Bar

At Lucky's Bar, every bite is a delightful journey! The crispy crust is perfectly charred, providing a satisfying crunch that complements the rich, zesty tomato sauce. Topped with a generous layer of melted cheese and fresh toppings, each slice bursts with flavor. I savored their signature pepperoni pizza, which features an irresistible medley of spices that elevate this classic to new heights. The atmosphere is equally inviting, making it the perfect spot for a casual night out. If you’re seeking a slice of pizza perfection in Zanesville, Lucky's Bar is a must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.

Weasel Boy Brewing Company

From the moment I stepped into Weasel Boy Brewing Company, the atmosphere was buzzing with charm and creativity. Their artisan pizzas are a delightful fusion of fresh ingredients and unique flavors. I savored the Margherita pizza, topped with a perfect blend of mozzarella and basil, which was both comforting and invigorating. The crust had that ideal balance of crispy and chewy that every pizza lover craves. Pairing it with one of their craft brews elevated the experience to a whole new level! If you’re hunting for a standout pie in Zanesville, don’t miss this hidden gem – it’s a slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

Keck's Pies and Pints

Nestled in the heart of Zanesville, Keck's Pies and Pints offers a delightful twist on classic pizza. The crust is a perfect blend of crispy and chewy, providing a solid foundation for their innovative toppings. I couldn’t resist the Buffalo Chicken, which was packed with flavor and just the right amount of spice. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff made my visit even more enjoyable. Pairing my pizza with one of their craft beers was the cherry on top of this culinary adventure. For a unique slice of goodness, Keck's is definitely a must-try in Zanesville!

You might also want to check out the best fish and chips in Columbus.