Best Pizza in Columbus: Our Expert Picks for 2026

Whether you’re a lifelong resident or just passing through, there’s no denying that Columbus has some seriously mouthwatering pizza options. After diving deep into the local scene and sampling slices from 13 of the top spots, I can confidently say that this city knows how to craft a pie.

Trust me, I’ve tasted everything from classic pepperoni to innovative gourmet creations, and each bite has added to my pizza-loving journey. With a passion that runs deeper than a cheese pull, I’m here to help you navigate this delicious landscape and uncover your next favorite slice. Get ready to embark on a cheesy adventure that’ll leave your taste buds dancing!

Plank's Cafe & Pizzeria

Highlights
Sweet and dry pizza crust
Unwelcoming service experience
Cramped and uncomfortable atmosphere
Disappointing country fried steak
Poor quality breakfast options

Review of Plank's Cafe & Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, Plank's Cafe & Pizzeria offers an interesting blend of classic pizza and quirky charm. My visit was quite the adventure, marked by an array of unique experiences. First, let's talk about the pizza crust—a delightful balance of sweet and dry that kept me coming back for more. Each slice was an ode to the fundamentals of pizza making.

However, the ambiance left much to be desired. The café felt a bit cramped and uncomfortable, making it challenging to fully immerse myself in the culinary delights. Additionally, the service was somewhat unwelcoming, which added a layer of awkwardness to my dining experience. As tempting as the breakfast options sounded, they turned out to be a disappointment, leaving me longing for something more satisfying.

Despite these hiccups, the pizza itself was a highlight worth savoring. With each bite, I found a blend of flavors that made me appreciate the potential in this establishment. While Plank's might not be perfect, it has the heart of a pizza lover’s retreat. Would I recommend it? Absolutely, but with a sprinkle of caution!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Columbus.

Terita's Pizza

Highlights
Really good pizza
Worth the trip
Homemade sausage standout
Low key takeout location
Best pizza in Columbus

Terita's Pizza is truly a hidden gem that is well worth the drive! As soon as I stepped into this low-key takeout location, I could sense the cozy atmosphere that welcomes all pizza lovers. The star of the show? The homemade sausage—a standout feature that elevates their pizzas to a whole new level.

I opted for their classic pepperoni slice, and let me tell you, the balance of flavors was absolutely divine. The fresh ingredients and perfectly baked crust made each bite a delightful experience. I was impressed by how their pizza manages to feel both indulgent and comforting; it's clear that great care goes into every pie they create.

Whether you're a lifelong pizza aficionado or just someone in search of a satisfying meal, Terita's Pizza deserves a spot on your must-try list. Spoiler alert: it might just become your new favorite! So, if you're in Columbus, don’t miss out on this delicious pilgrimage—it’s some of the best pizza you'll find in the city! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best burger in Columbus.

Rubinos Pizza

Highlights
Time-honored Italian tradition
Unique immigrant style crust
Crispy thin crust perfection
Cash-only simple dining experience
Delicious thick red pizza sauce

Rubinos Pizza is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, and stepping inside, you’re instantly transported to a world steeped in time-honored Italian tradition. The moment I laid eyes on their unique immigrant style crust, I knew I was in for a treat. This creation is a masterclass in crafting perfect thin crust: crispy, yet surprisingly light.

As I bit into the slice, the delicious thick red pizza sauce burst forth, offering an exquisite balance of flavors that danced on my palate. It was the kind of sauce that could only be born from generations of pizza-making lore. The toppings—each ingredient carefully curated—enhanced the pizza without overwhelming the senses.

One quirky aspect of Rubinos is the cash-only dining experience, which gives it a simple, almost nostalgic ambiance. It felt like stepping into a local haunt where the focus is purely on the food, not flashy decor. Although the seating might be minimal, trust me, it only adds to the charm!

If you're looking for crispy thin crust perfection paired with authentic flavors, Rubinos Pizza deserves a top spot in your Columbus pizza journey. 🥳🍕

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

The O on Lane

Highlights
Excellent friendly service
A+ delicious pepperoni pizza
Nice atmosphere and vibe
Fast food during game days
Lively music for parties

I recently tried The O on Lane in Columbus, and let me tell you, it was a delightful experience! The moment I stepped in, I was greeted with a warm welcome that set the tone for the evening. The friendly service here makes you feel like part of the family, and that's always a plus.

Now, let's talk about the pizza. I couldn't resist ordering their signature pepperoni pizza, and wow, it was an absolute A+. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce had just the right tang, and the generous layers of pepperoni were succulent and savory. It’s the kind of pizza that makes you shout, “More, please!”

The atmosphere was vibrant, filled with lively music that kept spirits high. It made for a great spot to unwind, especially on game days when the excitement is palpable. If you’re looking for a place where fun meets fantastic flavors, The O on Lane is a must-visit. This isn’t just pizza; it’s an experience that leaves you wanting more!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Adriatico's New York Style Pizza

Stepping into Adriatico's New York Style Pizza felt like a trip to the Big Apple itself! The aroma of fresh dough and tangy sauce embraced me as I scanned the menu. I opted for a classic pepperoni slice, and it did not disappoint. The crust was delightfully crispy yet wonderfully chewy, while the generous toppings sang harmoniously with each bite. The rich tomato sauce danced alongside the perfectly melted cheese, creating a slice that was both memorable and indulgent. For anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza in Columbus, Adriatico’s should be at the top of your list! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best steak in Columbus.

The Pizza House

The Pizza House in Columbus truly delivers on flavor! As soon as I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked dough and zesty sauce enveloped me. I opted for their signature Margherita pizza, which showcased a perfect balance of tangy tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil. The thin crust was delightfully crispy yet pliable—ideal for folding! Each bite felt like a warm hug, making it hard to resist a second slice. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff only added to the charm. If you're seeking pizza that dances on your palate, The Pizza House is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Columbus.

Hounddog's Pizza

Hounddog's Pizza is a delightful gem in Columbus, where each bite feels like a joyful celebration. The crust is a perfect harmony of crispy and chewy, holding up beautifully under generous toppings. I couldn't resist the famous Hounddog’s Special, which bursts with flavors that dance on the palate. The fresh ingredients and mouthwatering sauce elevate every slice to a level of deliciousness that's hard to match. Plus, the quirky atmosphere and friendly staff add to the charm. If you're hunting for a place that knows pizza, look no further than Hounddog's—where every pie is a love letter to your taste buds! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Columbus.

Paulie Gee's Short North

From the moment I stepped into Paulie Gee's Short North, the vibrant ambiance set the stage for a delightful experience. The wood-fired pizzas here are simply outstanding—each bite combines a perfectly charred crust with a medley of fresh toppings. I indulged in the Hellboy, featuring spicy honey that danced wonderfully with the smoky flavor. The service was warm and welcoming, making me feel like part of the family. If you're seeking a pizza that balances innovation with tradition, Paulie Gee’s is a must-visit. Don’t miss out on this gem—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

GoreMade Pizza

GoreMade Pizza in Columbus is a delightful culinary adventure that delivers an innovative twist on classic pies. As I took my first bite, the flavors danced on my palate—each slice was a perfect blend of quality ingredients and bold toppings. Their signature "Gore-Feta" combo left me craving more, while the dough was light, yet satisfying, offering a crispy crust that held up beautifully. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff added to the charm, making it a perfect spot for pizza lovers. If you’re searching for a pizza that’s both creative and delicious, GoreMade should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Pizzanos Express

Stepping into Pizzanos Express felt like entering a cozy slice of Italy. The aroma of freshly baked dough envelops you as you make your way to the counter. I opted for their signature pepperoni pizza, and oh, what a delight it was! The crust was perfectly crispy – a wonderful gateway to the rich, zesty sauce beneath. Each pepperoni slice was a savory burst of flavor, perfectly balanced by the generous cheese blanket. What truly sets this gem apart is the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff. For a casual pizza night, Pizzanos is a must-try destination in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

East Pizzeria

East Pizzeria in Columbus dazzled me with its expertly crafted pies. The crust was a perfect blend of crispy and chewy, providing an excellent base for their bold toppings. I savored the Margherita, where the fresh basil danced atop a rich marinara and gooey mozzarella, creating a delightful harmony of flavors. The atmosphere was vibrant yet inviting, making it a great spot to enjoy a slice or two with friends. If you're seeking pizza that combines quality and flair, look no further than East Pizzeria. This charming eatery elevated my pizza expectations to a whole new level!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Harvest Bar + Kitchen - Brewery District

During my visit to Harvest Bar + Kitchen - Brewery District, I was delighted to discover their artisan pizza selection. The thin, crisp crust was a perfect canvas for the fresh, locally sourced ingredients—each bite was bursting with flavor! I opted for the seasonal veggie pizza, topped with vibrant greens and a drizzle of balsamic reduction that danced on my palate. The warm, inviting atmosphere paired with their craft brews made for an enjoyable dining experience. If you're seeking a slice that’s as innovative as it is delicious, look no further—this spot is a true gem in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Columbus.

Harvest Bar + Kitchen - Clintonville

During my visit to Harvest Bar + Kitchen - Clintonville, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere and exquisite aromas wafting from the kitchen. I opted for their signature pizza, which features a crispy thin crust topped with fresh, local ingredients—each bite bursting with flavor! The smoky richness of the house-made sauce perfectly complemented the artisanal cheeses. Paired with a refreshing salad, this culinary combination redefined my expectations of pizza. If you’re hunting for a slice that balances creativity and quality, look no further! Harvest is a delightful gem in Columbus, bringing elegance to this beloved comfort food.

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.