The Absolute Best Pie in Columbus [Updated 2025]

From the moment I took my first bite of a warm, buttery crust filled with rich, spiced apples at a local bakery, I knew Columbus had something special to offer pie lovers. The sweet aroma wafting through the air, mixed with the laughter of families enjoying their treats, made it clear that this city is a hidden gem for dessert enthusiasts.

In my quest to find the best pie in Columbus, I visited 12 top locations, each with its own unique twist on traditional flavors and creative concoctions. With my taste buds fully engaged and my heart open to new experiences, I’ve unearthed the very best that this vibrant culinary scene has to offer. Trust me, you won't want to miss these pie paradise spots!

Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.

Highlights
Custom cakes available
Fresh and flavorful treats
Impressive selection
Easy online ordering
Moist, delicious scones

When I stepped into Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co., I felt as though I had entered a fairytale of baked delights. The aroma of freshly baked goods wafted through the air, instantly setting the mood for a delightful pie adventure. Their impressive selection of pastries lured me in, but it was the promise of pie that kept me there.

I decided to indulge in their signature cherry pie, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of magical. The crust was perfectly flaky, cradling a luscious filling that was bursting with flavor. Each bite was a symphony of sweet and tart, singing a tune that reminded me of sun-soaked summers and warm gatherings.

What truly impressed me was the option for custom cakes, hinting that this establishment takes its baking seriously, but it was the ease of online ordering that made it even more accessible. To top it all off, I couldn’t resist trying one of their renowned scones—moist and delightful, enhancing my already splendid experience.

Overall, Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co. is a charming destination for pie lovers, and if you're in Columbus, a slice of pie here is a must!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Columbus.

Pattycake Bakery

Highlights
Delicious vegan desserts
Friendly and pleasant staff
Always fresh offerings
Comfortable atmosphere
Long-standing reputation

Pattycake Bakery: The Vegan Delight in the Heart of Columbus

As I stepped into Pattycake Bakery, I was welcomed by the aroma of freshly baked goods that danced playfully in the air. This cozy haven, known for its delicious vegan desserts, immediately captured my heart. The staff members were not only friendly, but radiated enthusiasm that made the atmosphere feel like an embrace.

Now, let’s talk about the pies. Each offering is a testament to creativity and flavor—made fresh daily, which is apparent in every bite. I was particularly enchanted by their seasonal berry pie, bursting with vibrant flavors that danced on my palate like a summer festival. The crust was perfectly flaky, cradling the luscious filling in a manner that made my taste buds sing.

Another delightful feature? The long-standing reputation of Pattycake for excellence. It’s clear that this bakery has worked hard to establish itself within the community, and it shows in the devotion of the staff and the quality of their offerings.

If you’re in Columbus and craving dessert that pushes boundaries while also being kind to the planet, I wholeheartedly recommend you visit Pattycake Bakery! It’s not just pie; it’s a celebration of flavor and compassion!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Cherbourg Bakery

Highlights
Freshly baked daily
Best gluten-free bakery
Flaky quiche crust
Delicious gluten-free donuts
Friendly and welcoming staff

During my recent pilgrimage to Cherbourg Bakery, I discovered a gluten-free haven that has captured my heart (and taste buds!). Nestled in a cozy corner of Columbus, this delightful spot is celebrated for its freshly baked pies that embody both flavor and artistry.

What struck me the most was the quiche with its delightfully flaky crust, a feat that leaves many gluten-free establishments in the dust. Each slice was a perfect harmony of rich fillings and herby goodness, and I must admit, I was tempted to have seconds (or thirds!).

As I explored their menu, I couldn’t resist trying their famed gluten-free donuts, which were light, fluffy, and oh-so-sweet—the perfect companion to a cup of coffee.

The staff at Cherbourg were not only friendly but genuinely passionate about their creations, which added a personal touch to my visit. They clearly take pride in crafting every delicious morsel, creating an inviting atmosphere that encourages you to linger a little longer.

If you're on the hunt for mouthwatering pies that cater to gluten-free diets, make Cherbourg Bakery your next stop. I promise, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Smith Farm Market

Highlights
Freshness and charm
Beautifully grown produce
Magnificent chocolate cream pie
Larger, expanded market space
Family-friendly atmosphere

Smith Farm Market is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, where freshness and charm collide in the most delightful way. As I stepped through the doors of their beautifully expanded market space, I was greeted by the vibrant colors of their locally grown produce. But let's be real; I was there for one thing and one thing only: pie.

Their magnificent chocolate cream pie deserves a standing ovation! The rich, velvety chocolate filling danced on my taste buds, perfectly complemented by a light and flaky crust that cradled it just right. Each forkful was a reminder that sometimes, the simplest ingredients create the most extraordinary flavors.

Beyond just the pie, the family-friendly atmosphere made my visit even more enjoyable, with laughter and chatter filling the air. It's evident that Smith Farm Market isn't just about selling pies; it's about creating an experience. If you're in Columbus and craving something sweet, make sure to stop by. You might just find a slice of happiness waiting for you, along with a newfound appreciation for the heart and soul that goes into every bite! 🍰✨

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Columbus.

Belle's Bread Japanese Bakery and Café

Highlights
Fresh and delicious treats
Amazing soft roll cakes
Welcoming and helpful staff
Delicious chocolate cake
Great location in shopping center

Belle's Bread Japanese Bakery and Café is a delightful gem tucked away in a bustling shopping center, and let me tell you, it’s a must-visit for any pie enthusiast. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the warm aroma of freshly baked goods that instantly put a smile on my face. The welcoming and helpful staff made my experience even more enjoyable as they guided me through their delightful offerings.

While I must admit I was tempted by their mouthwatering soft roll cakes and delectable chocolate cake, I was particularly on a mission to sample their pie selection. Their Japanese-inspired pie is nothing short of a revelation — delicate and perfectly balanced, it combines traditional flavors with a modern twist. Each bite reveals a surprising depth of taste that will have you yearning for more.

In this vibrant atmosphere, you'll find not just exceptional pies but an array of treats perfect for any palate. Belle's Bread is more than just a bakery; it’s a heartfelt tribute to the love of pastry craftsmanship. If you're hunting for the best pie in Columbus, don’t miss this delightful spot!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Dough Mama Clintonville

Stepping into Dough Mama Clintonville feels like a warm hug on a chilly day! Their seasonal peach pie is a symphony of sweet and tart, enveloped in a perfectly flaky crust that crumbles delightfully with each bite. The luscious filling dances on the palate, making it hard to resist a second slice (or third!). I appreciate their commitment to local ingredients, which enhances the flavors beautifully. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff only add to the charm. If you’re in search of a slice of happiness, Dough Mama is a must-try in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

The Bearded Baker

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, The Bearded Baker offers a playful twist on traditional pies that had me grinning from ear to ear. Their signature blueberry basil pie is a delightful fusion, balancing sweet and savory with every bite. The flaky crust is a testament to their craftsmanship, while the unexpected herbaceous notes create a symphony of flavors that dances on the palate. I savored each slice, feeling like a kid in a candy store. With their warm atmosphere and charming presentation, The Bearded Baker has undoubtedly earned its place among the top pie contenders in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Junior's Sweetpotato Pie

Upon stepping into Junior's Sweetpotato Pie, I was greeted by the rich aroma of spiced sweet potatoes that instantly warmed my soul. This delightful pie encapsulates the essence of comfort food—the crust is perfectly flaky, providing just the right balance to the sweet, creamy filling. Each bite reveals a luscious blend of cinnamon and nutmeg, transporting my taste buds to a cozy holiday kitchen. The distinctive flavor of sweet potatoes shines through, making it a stand-out treat. If you're looking for a slice of pure joy in Columbus, Junior's irresistible sweetpotato pie is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Just Pies Inc

Just Pies Inc is a delightful treasure nestled in Columbus that truly lives up to its name. As I stepped inside, the sweet aroma of freshly baked pastries enveloped me, teasing my taste buds. I sampled their signature cherry pie, and it was an explosion of flavor—perfectly sweet-tart with a flaky crust that crumbled just right. Each bite felt like a warm hug on a chilly day. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff only added to the charm. If you're searching for a slice of heaven, Just Pies Inc should be your next stop! Truly a must-visit for pie lovers!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

Ri'Joyce Pies

Ri'Joyce Pies in Columbus is a delightful treasure trove for pie enthusiasts! As I sank my fork into their signature blueberry bliss, I was greeted with a burst of sweet-tart flavor, perfectly complemented by a flaky crust that practically melts in your mouth. Each slice told a story of craftsmanship, with just the right amount of spice and a delicate sweetness that dances on the palate. The cheerful ambiance and friendly staff made my visit even more enjoyable. If you’re seeking a slice of happiness, Ri'Joyce Pies is a must-visit destination that will leave your taste buds singing!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Resch's Bakery

At Resch's Bakery, the minute I stepped inside, the intoxicating aroma of fresh-baked pie whisked me away to dessert heaven. I sampled their signature apple pie, which boasted a tender, buttery crust cradling perfectly spiced apples. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors, with just the right amount of sweetness. The flaky crust was so good, it could stand alone as a star! The welcoming staff added a sprinkle of warmth to the experience. If you’re on the hunt for the best pie in Columbus, look no further than Resch's, where every slice tells a delicious story!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Columbus.

The Pastry Factory

At The Pastry Factory, I indulged in a slice of their signature berry pie that danced on my palate. The crust was a buttery dream—flaky yet sturdy, cradling a medley of fresh berries that burst with flavor. Each bite was a delightful balance of sweet and tart, perfectly complemented by a touch of cinnamon. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, ideal for pie enthusiasts like myself. It’s clear that each recipe is crafted with care and creativity. If you’re in search of a delicious piece of pie in Columbus, this gem deserves a top spot on your list!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Columbus.