Worthington's Best Pizza [Updated 2026]

The aroma of freshly baked dough mingled with rich tomato sauce and bubbling cheese is nothing short of magic. I can still remember the first time I bit into a slice that had just come out of the oven—crispy on the outside, perfectly chewy on the inside, and a burst of flavor that sent my taste buds into a frenzy. After scouring Worthington and sampling from twelve of the top pizzerias, I’ve become something of a local expert on this beloved dish.

Trust me, I’ve navigated the cheesy landscapes and tangy sauces so that you don’t have to. Whether you’re a thin-crust lover or a deep-dish devotee, my picks are sure to satisfy your cravings and perhaps even spark your own pizza adventure in our charming town!

Borgata Pizza Cafe

Highlights
Best New York style pizza
Exceptional service staff
Great topping choices
Delicious pasta dishes
Fantastic happy hour

Visiting Borgata Pizza Cafe was an experience worthy of a pizza pilgrimage. Known for its New York style pizza, I was eager to dive into a slice that promised both quality and authenticity. As I walked in, the ambiance was delightful—with pizza-loving patrons and a lively atmosphere that simply screams comfort.

The service staff at Borgata is nothing short of exceptional. My server greeted me with warmth and recommended a few of their popular toppings. I couldn’t resist the allure of the pepperoni and fresh basil combo, and let me tell you—each bite was like a small celebration in my mouth! The crust was just the right amount of crispy, laying a perfect foundation for the generous portions of cheese that melted like dreams.

Additionally, I discovered they offer delicious pasta dishes, which made me wish for a second stomach. What elevated my visit further was their fantastic happy hour, a treat for anyone looking to unwind with some incredible eats after a long day.

In conclusion, Borgata Pizza Cafe is a must-visit for any pizza aficionado in Worthington! Their commitment to quality and service sets them apart, making this spot a true gem in the heart of the community.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Columbus.

Joya's

Highlights
Amazing lattes
Fantastic breakfast sandwich
Great service
Cute, quiet atmosphere
Delicious kathi with sauce

Joya’s Pizza: A Slice of Worthington Delight

Stepping into Joya’s is like entering a cozy culinary retreat. The charming atmosphere is inviting, perfect for both leisurely breakfasts and tasty lunches. I was thrilled to find an amazing latte on the menu; it sets a delightful tone before diving into their pizza offerings.

Now, let's talk pizza! Joya’s boasts a diverse menu, but I was particularly intrigued by their unique toppings and fresh ingredients. Each slice was a flavour explosion, striking that perfect balance between crispy crust and savory toppings. I also indulged in their fantastic breakfast sandwich—a must-try that brims with local flavors.

What sets Joya’s apart is the attentive service. The team here truly knows how to make customers feel special, which enhances the overall dining experience. It’s a quiet spot, ideal for unwinding with a meal or enjoying a slice while catching up with friends.

Oh, and do not overlook their delicious kathi with sauce! It’s a harmonious accompaniment to their pizzas that beautifully blends taste and texture.

In a town overflowing with pizza options, Joya's stands out as a delightful gem in Worthington. I can’t wait to return for more!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Columbus.

Dewey's Pizza

Dewey's Pizza is a delightful gem in Worthington that truly elevates the pizza game. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere that promised a good time. I indulged in their wonderfully unique Dewey's Special, a mouthwatering blend of fresh ingredients and bold flavors that danced on my taste buds. The crust? Perfectly crispy with just the right amount of chew. Each bite was a tantalizing reminder of why I love pizza so much. If you’re searching for something beyond the ordinary, Dewey's Pizza is a must-visit for any pizza aficionado! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH is a delightful find that combines creativity with classic flavors. From the moment I entered, the vibrant atmosphere set the tone for a fun dining experience. Their unique specialty pizzas, like the Cranberry and Goat Cheese, truly delighted my taste buds, offering a harmonious balance of sweet and savory. The crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy, while their extensive craft beer selection complements any slice beautifully. If you’re in search of a playful twist on traditional pizza, look no further than this gem in Worthington – it’s sure to keep you coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Villa Nova Ristorante

At Villa Nova Ristorante, I was greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza. Their Margherita Pizza truly stole the show with its perfectly crisp crust, topped with vibrant tomatoes and creamy mozzarella. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors that transported me straight to Italy. The staff's warmth added to the experience, making me feel like part of the family. If you’re seeking an authentic slice, look no further! Villa Nova is definitely a slice of paradise in Worthington, where every pie tells a story. Don't miss it! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best steak in Columbus.

The Pizza House

From the moment I stepped into The Pizza House, the mouthwatering aroma enveloped me, sparking excitement for what was to come. The menu boasts creative toppings, but I opted for the classic margherita. Each bite revealed a perfect balance of fresh basil, tangy sauce, and gooey mozzarella. The crust was delightfully crisp yet chewy, a superb vessel for the flavors. The charming atmosphere and friendly staff made it feel like a second home. If you're in Worthington and craving pizza, The Pizza House should definitely be on your radar—it’s an experience that leaves your taste buds dancing!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Columbus.

JT's Pizza & Pub - Linworth

From the moment I stepped into JT's Pizza & Pub - Linworth, I was struck by its lively atmosphere. Their fearless approach to toppings truly made my heart sing! I opted for the "JT's Favorite" – a delightful blend of pepperoni, sausage, and fresh veggies atop a perfectly crispy crust. Each bite was a celebration of flavors, with just the right amount of cheese stretching as I savored it. The friendly staff further enhanced my visit, making me feel like part of the family. If you’re on the hunt for pizza that’s both delicious and fun, JT's is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Columbus.

Worthington Tavern

My recent visit to Worthington Tavern was nothing short of delightful! The ambiance was welcoming, and the aroma of fresh pizza wafting through the air instantly teased my taste buds. I indulged in their signature Tavern Deluxe, a marvelous blend of savory toppings on a perfectly baked crust. Each bite was a symphony of flavors—crispy, cheesy, and just the right amount of zest. The attentive staff added to the overall charm of the experience. If you're on the hunt for a pizza that combines quality with a laid-back vibe, look no further than Worthington Tavern! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Worthington Pizza Primo

Nestled in the heart of Worthington, Worthington Pizza Primo is a delightful gem that whetted my appetite for adventure. As I entered, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me like a warm hug. I opted for their signature Margherita, and let me tell you—the crust was the perfect balance of chewy and crispy, with a generous layer of sun-ripened tomatoes and fragrant basil. Each bite was a burst of flavor that danced on my palate, making it difficult to resist a second slice. If you're in pursuit of the finest pizza, this spot is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

East Coast Pizzeria

East Coast Pizzeria in Worthington is a delightful slice of New York charm right in the heart of Ohio. The crust is perfectly crisp, providing a solid foundation for a medley of fresh toppings that burst with flavor. I couldn’t resist the classic margherita, topped with aromatic basil and rich mozzarella—a true homage to Italian tradition. The cozy atmosphere adds to the experience, making it a perfect spot for casual gatherings. If you're craving a pizza that delivers both taste and ambiance, East Coast Pizzeria should be at the top of your list! Enjoy each bite! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta

At Big Tony's Pizza & Pasta, every bite is a delightful adventure! The moment I stepped in, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza wrapped around me like a warm hug. I opted for the classic pepperoni – a perfectly golden crust that held a generous layer of zesty sauce, melty cheese, and just the right amount of spicy pepperoni. Each slice was a carnival of flavors, leaving me yearning for more. The atmosphere was busy yet homey, making it a fantastic spot for gatherings. If you're hunting for a slice that feels like a party in your mouth, Big Tony's is an absolute must-try! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Big Apple Breakfast Co

Tucked away in Worthington, Big Apple Breakfast Co is a delightful surprise for pizza lovers, especially at brunch! Their Breakfast Pizza, a masterpiece adorned with fluffy eggs, crispy bacon, and gooey cheese, is a morning game-changer. The crust strikes the perfect balance between crispiness and chewiness, making each bite irresistibly satisfying. What sets this joint apart is their playful twist on traditional flavors, ensuring you don’t just have pizza but a whimsical brunch experience. If you’re in the area, don’t miss this gem for a pizza that dances on your palate while giving a nod to breakfast bliss!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Columbus.