Westerville's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

With each bite of cheesy goodness, I’ve experienced the thrill of finding the perfect slice right here in my hometown. The aroma of fresh dough mingling with rich tomato sauce transports me back to cozy nights with friends, laughter echoing through the air as we devour pie after pie. After scouring 12 of the top pizza spots around Westerville, I’ve tasted everything from classic pepperoni to innovative toppings that’ll make your taste buds dance.

Trust me, I've got a knack for sniffing out the good stuff, and I can't wait to guide you through my favorites. Whether you’re a die-hard pizza lover or just in the mood for a casual night out, I promise there’s something on this list that will make your mouth water!

High Bank Distillery Co. Westerville

Highlights
First-rate cocktails
Unique brunch offerings
Friendly service team
Flavorful honey hummus
Variety of ingredients

Visiting High Bank Distillery Co. Westerville was nothing short of delightful, especially when it came to their pizza offerings. As I perused the menu, I was captivated by the unique selection of ingredients. Each pizza boasts a distinct personality, fusing creativity with classic flavors that truly tantalize the taste buds.

I opted for the signature pizza, a tantalizing mix topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients that left a lasting impression. The crust was perfectly baked, achieving that enticing balance between crispy and chewy. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors, while the friendly service team made me feel right at home.

To complement my meal, I indulged in their first-rate cocktails, each one crafted with the same care and precision as their food. These innovative drinks paired beautifully with my pizza, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to my dining experience.

Don’t overlook their unique brunch offerings as well—it’s the perfect way to spend a weekend morning. All in all, High Bank Distillery Co. Westerville not only excels in pizza but also creates a warm and inviting atmosphere that is simply hard to resist.

You might also want to check out the best burger in Columbus.

Grizzlybird Brewing Company

Highlights
Friendly and personable staff
Fun and lively atmosphere
Great beer selection
Games and pinball machines
Hidden gem in Westerville

Grizzlybird Brewing Company is a delightful discovery in the heart of Westerville, where the friendly and personable staff immediately makes you feel at home. The atmosphere is fun and lively, with plenty of ambiance generated by laughter and the clinking of glasses. As I settled in, I couldn't resist taking a moment to admire their great beer selection, which pairs perfectly with their delicious pie offerings.

The pizza here is a true testament to what makes this spot a hidden gem. The crust strikes the ideal balance between crispy and chewy, providing the perfect foundation for bold toppings. One bite and I was transported, savoring the harmonious blend of flavors.

Adding to the charm of Grizzlybird, there are games and pinball machines scattered throughout the space, inviting patrons to engage in a bit of nostalgic fun while they wait for their meal.

In all, Grizzlybird Brewing Company offers more than just pizza; it delivers a memorable experience that intertwines a relaxing environment with mouthwatering food. If you're on the hunt for a cozy nook with exceptional pizza and a lively vibe, look no further than this local treasure!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House

With its inviting atmosphere and authentic Italian flair, Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House truly stands out. The moment I took a bite of their classic pepperoni pizza, I was transported to pizza perfection! The crust had the ideal balance of crispiness and chewiness, while the classic tomato sauce danced joyfully with the generous cheese and expertly placed pepperoni. Each slice revealed a delightful flavor explosion that kept me coming back for more. The friendly staff and cozy vibe made this visit even more enjoyable. If you’re looking for top-notch pizza in Westerville, Pasquale’s is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Antonio's

Antonio's in Westerville truly wowed me with its flavorful pie that elegantly balances tradition and innovation. The crust is a delightful blend of crispy and chewy, perfectly supporting the generous toppings. I opted for their signature Margherita, and each bite was a celebration of fresh basil, rich mozzarella, and a tangy tomato sauce that danced on my palate. The ambiance is cozy, encouraging you to linger longer over that slice (or two). If you're searching for a pizza adventure that makes your taste buds sing, Antonio's is a must-try destination in Westerville! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best steak in Columbus.

Giammarco's Italian Restaurant

From the moment I stepped into Giammarco's Italian Restaurant, the aroma of freshly baked pizza enveloped me like a warm hug. Their signature thin crust is a delightful canvas, supporting a symphony of flavors that dance on your palate. I sampled the classic Margherita, and the balance of fresh mozzarella, vibrant basil, and zesty tomato sauce was simply sublime. The friendly staff added to the warm atmosphere, making me feel right at home. If you're on the hunt for a pizza that feels both authentic and comforting, Giammarco's is a must-try in Westerville! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Columbus.

Gionino's Pizzeria

From the moment I walked into Gionino's Pizzeria, the delightful aroma of fresh-baked dough enveloped me like a warm hug. Their signature pizza is a masterpiece of flavors, with a perfectly crispy crust and rich, savory sauce that dances with each bite. The generous portions of cheese meld beautifully with a variety of toppings, creating a flavor symphony that’s hard to resist. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it clear that passion for pizza runs deep here. Whether you dine in or take out, Gionino’s definitely ranks high on my list of must-try spots in Westerville!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Columbus.

Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen

Nestled in the heart of Westerville, Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen is a delightful gem that truly understands the art of pizza-making. Their signature crust is perfectly crispy yet chewy, creating a fantastic foundation for the vibrant toppings. I indulged in their classic Margherita, where the fresh basil danced gracefully over the rich tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella. What truly sets Carsonie's apart is the playful blend of flavors that keep you coming back for more. If you're on a quest for pizza perfection, look no further—Carsonie's is a slice of happiness you don’t want to miss! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Cardinal Pizza

At Cardinal Pizza, I discovered a delightful culinary gem! The moment I stepped in, the inviting aroma of fresh dough and zesty tomato sauce enveloped me. Opting for their signature Cardinal Supreme, I was met with a masterpiece of toppings that danced on my palate—each bite a perfect blend of flavors. The crust was a sublime combination of crunchy and chewy, and the generous cheese pull had me grinning like a kid. If you're in Westerville and craving a slice, don't miss out on this pizzeria. Cardinal Pizza is a true slice of joy!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Giordano's

At Giordano's, every bite is an adventure! Their famous stuffed pizza is a dreamy delight, boasting layers of cheese and toppings enveloped in a perfectly baked crust. The rich tomato sauce on top adds a vibrant burst of flavor that has you reaching for more. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it a perfect spot for family gatherings or a cozy date night. What truly sets it apart, though, is the dedication to quality—you can taste the love in each slice. If you're in Westerville and craving authentic pizza, Giordano's is a must-visit that promises to delight! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Carfagna's Ristorante

Stepping into Carfagna's Ristorante feels like a warm embrace from an Italian grandmother. The wood-fired pizza here is nothing short of spectacular! The crust strikes that perfect balance—crispy on the outside, yet delightfully chewy within. I savored their Margherita pizza, where the fresh mozzarella danced beautifully with basil and a zesty tomato sauce. Each bite is a celebration of flavors that transport you straight to Italy! Don’t skip the garlic knots either; they’re the perfect dance partner for your pizza. Overall, if you're in Westerville and craving a slice of heaven, Carfagna's is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Minico's Italian Restaurant

Nestled in the heart of Westerville, Minico's Italian Restaurant is a delightful gem for pizza lovers. Their thin-crust pizza strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, delivering a delightful texture with every bite. I savored the Margherita, where the fresh basil danced atop a delightful blend of sauce and mozzarella. The flavors were vibrant yet harmonious, almost poetic! The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a cozy spot for families and friends alike. If you're seeking a slice that embodies the essence of Italian comfort food, Minico's is a must-visit. 🍕

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Columbus.

Cardone's Restaurant & Bar

Cardone's Restaurant & Bar is a delightful gem nestled in Westerville, serving up pizza that's nothing short of spectacular. The crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy, while their house-made sauce bursts with flavor. I opted for the Margherita, and its fresh basil and mozzarella felt like a culinary hug. The ambiance is cozy yet vibrant, inviting you to linger with friends over a slice (or two!). If you're in the mood for a pizza experience that tickles your taste buds and warms your soul, Cardone's is a must-visit spot in this charming town. 🎉🍕

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.