Pickerington's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

From the moment I stepped into my first local pizzeria, the aroma of bubbling mozzarella and the tang of fresh tomato sauce enveloped me like a warm hug. I've spent countless evenings sampling slices, from crispy thin crusts to thick, cheesy masterpieces, and trust me when I say my taste buds have never been happier. After savoring 12 of the top spots in town, I’ve uncovered the hidden gems and local favorites that will make your heart sing and your stomach dance.

You can trust my expertise because I’m not just a pizza lover; I’m a passionate connoisseur who believes every slice tells a story. Whether you're a die-hard pepperoni fan or an adventurous foodie looking for unique toppings, I've got you covered. Grab a slice and join me on this flavorful journey through Pickerington’s best pizza!

Pizza Cottage

Highlights
Great Ohio style pizza
Delicious toppings selection
Family-friendly atmosphere
Consistency in quality
Room for staff improvement

When I stepped into Pizza Cottage, I was instantly drawn to its family-friendly atmosphere, which radiated warmth and comfort—perfect for a casual night out. As I settled in, I couldn't help but get excited about their great Ohio style pizza. After a quick glance at the menu, I was captivated by the impressive selection of toppings, allowing for a truly customizable pizza experience.

I opted for the classic pepperoni with extra cheese, and let me tell you, it was a slice of bliss! The crust was perfectly baked, offering that ideal crunch while supporting a generous layer of toppings. Each bite was a delightful medley of flavors that spoke to the consistency in quality they've mastered over the years.

While the food had me swooning, I noticed a bit of a lag in service. This is a lovely place, but I must admit, there's room for staff improvement. Nonetheless, the pizza made up for any minor hiccups. If you’re hunting for the best pizza in Pickerington, look no further than Pizza Cottage—it’s a slice of happiness that I’ll surely return to!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Grapevine Pizza & Cafe

Highlights
Best pizza and sandwiches around
Quick and attentive service
Fun and friendly atmosphere
Usually no long wait times
Family-friendly dining experience

Review of Grapevine Pizza & Cafe

Stepping into Grapevine Pizza & Cafe feels like being welcomed into a cozy family gathering—where the warmth of the atmosphere is only rivaled by the delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a cheerful staff who made sure my visit was nothing short of delightful. It’s a place where laughter dances in the air, promising an experience that’s as enjoyable as the food itself.

Now, let’s talk pizza! The first slice I tried was their signature Grapevine Special. The crust was a perfect balance between crunchy and chewy, while the toppings were generously heaped without overwhelming each other. Each bite was a flavor explosion that had my taste buds singing.

Not only is Grapevine known for its stellar pizza, but their sandwiches also deserve a shout-out. I had the chance to sample a turkey club, and it was a fantastic accompaniment to my meal. What really sold me, though, was the quick and attentive service—no long waits here! If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Pickerington, Grapevine Pizza & Cafe is a must-try; you won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Little Sicily's Pizza

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Loaded with high-quality toppings
Thin but non-soggy crust
Local favorite spot
Impressive jalapeno poppers

At Little Sicily's Pizza, the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a team of friendly staff that immediately made me feel right at home. This local favorite spot isn't just about good vibes; it’s a haven for pizza lovers!

I decided to try their classic pepperoni pizza, and let me tell you, the toppings were loaded with high-quality ingredients that made each bite a delightful explosion of flavor. The thin crust had that perfect balance – crispy yet not too crispy, holding up beautifully to the generous toppings without a hint of sogginess.

I couldn't resist ordering their impressive jalapeño poppers as an appetizer, which were a delightful prelude to the pizza. The poppers were packed with flavor and had the right amount of heat to get the taste buds dancing.

Overall, my visit to Little Sicily's was a jubilant culinary adventure. The combination of their delectable pizzas and a warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a must-try for anyone in Pickerington. If you’re searching for a slice of happiness, look no further – Little Sicily's is where delicious dreams come true! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Hangry City Grille and Spirits

Highlights
Monthly special sliders
Fresh and flavorful food
Friendly and helpful staff
Quick service experience
Clean and organized space

Visiting Hangry City Grille and Spirits in Pickerington was an adventure that exceeded my expectations. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly and helpful staff that made me feel right at home. The atmosphere was clean and organized, creating an inviting space to enjoy a meal.

Now, let's talk about the pizza! The crust was perfectly baked—not too thick and not too thin—allowing the fresh, flavorful toppings to shine. Each bite was a symphony of tastes and textures, making it clear that they take pride in their preparation. I especially enjoyed their monthly special sliders, which added a fun twist to my dining experience.

One of the standout features was the quick service—just what a true pizza lover craves when hunger strikes! Whether you’re here with friends or in search of a casual night out, Hangry City Grille delivers on all fronts. If you’re in Pickerington and find yourself craving pizza, I highly recommend swinging by this hidden gem. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Beyond Dough Pizza

At Beyond Dough Pizza, I was instantly charmed by the cozy atmosphere and the wafting aroma of freshly baked pies. Their signature crust is a true delight—golden and crispy with just the right amount of chew. I indulged in the Margarita pizza, topped with ripe tomatoes and fragrant basil, which danced on my palate. The sauce was bursting with flavor, making each slice a triumph. Not only is the pizza great, but the staff radiates warmth and enthusiasm. If you're searching for a slice of happiness in Pickerington, Beyond Dough might just be your ultimate destination!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Cardo's Pizza & Tavern

Cardo's Pizza & Tavern offers a delightful pizza experience that truly pays homage to the art of pie-making. The thin, crispy crust was a pleasant surprise, perfectly complimenting the rich, marinara sauce and generous toppings. I opted for their signature Cardo’s Special, which was a savory explosion of flavors that left me craving more. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it an excellent spot for gatherings. Service was attentive, further enhancing the experience. If you’re in Pickerington and looking for a slice of heaven, Cardo's definitely deserves a spot on your must-try list! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Gionino's Pizzeria

Gionino's Pizzeria in Pickerington truly tantalized my taste buds! From the moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me in a warm, inviting embrace. I indulged in a classic pepperoni pie, and let me tell you, the crispy crust was perfectly balanced—crunchy on the outside yet delightfully chewy within. The generous layer of cheese melted like a dream, bringing harmony to every bite, while the pepperoni added just the right amount of spice. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a slice on the go, you can’t go wrong with this delicious masterpiece! 🍕 Highly recommended!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

Flyers Pizza Pickerington

During my visit to Flyers Pizza Pickerington, I was greeted by the comforting aroma of fresh dough and savory toppings. Their signature sauce is a delightful blend of herbs, perfectly complementing the gooey, melted cheese. I opted for the meaty masterpiece, and every bite delivered a satisfying explosion of flavor. The crust was wonderfully crispy, providing the ideal foundation for the toppings. The cozy atmosphere made it a great spot for a casual dinner. Overall, if you’re in Pickerington and craving a slice of happiness, I wholeheartedly recommend Flyers for a pizza experience that’s both delicious and fun!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Pickerington, Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria is a hidden gem that promises an unforgettable pizza experience. The moment I bit into their crispy, hand-tossed crust, I was transported to pizza paradise! Topped with fresh ingredients and a tangy, house-made sauce, every slice bursts with flavor. What truly sets Omezzo apart is their commitment to quality, combining tradition with a dash of creativity. The inviting atmosphere and friendly service make it the perfect spot for a casual night out or a family gathering. If you're hunting for pizza perfection, Omezzo is a must-try! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Columbus.

IL Forno

Nestled in the heart of Pickerington, IL Forno tantalizes taste buds with its authentic Italian charm. The moment I stepped in, the savory aroma of fresh dough and simmering sauce greeted me. I indulged in their signature Margherita, where the perfect blend of fresh basil and creamy mozzarella danced on my palate. The crust was pizza perfection: crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy within. It was clear that each pie is crafted with passion. If you’re hunting for a slice that embraces tradition, IL Forno is an absolute must-try—where every bite transports you straight to Italy! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.

Kingy's Pizza Pub

Stepping into Kingy's Pizza Pub felt like entering a cozy slice of heaven. The aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings instantly ignited my taste buds. Their signature Kingy’s Classic pizza boasts a perfect balance of gooey cheese and zesty sauce, making each bite a divine experience. The crust? Just the right amount of crispy, yet delightfully chewy. I also appreciated the welcoming atmosphere, with friendly staff eager to recommend their favorites. For anyone seeking a satisfying pizza adventure in Pickerington, Kingy's is a must-visit! The combination of flavor and ambiance keeps me coming back for more.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

Vick's Gourmet Pizza

Vick's Gourmet Pizza in Pickerington is a delightful culinary treasure! As I entered, the aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese greeted me like an old friend. I opted for their signature Margarita pizza, and wow, the balance of fresh basil, ripe tomatoes, and perfectly melted mozzarella was nothing short of spectacular. The crust was wonderfully crispy yet soft, inviting that perfect fold. Each bite was a celebration of flavors! Whether you're a local or just passing through, if you crave pizza that dances on your taste buds, Vick's Gourmet Pizza is an absolute must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best fish and chips in Columbus.