New Albany's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

The aroma of bubbling cheese and freshly baked crust wafted through the air as I embarked on my pizza quest, each bite promising a new adventure. After indulging in slices from twelve top-notch pizzerias, my taste buds have been on a thrilling rollercoaster, from classic pepperoni to unexpected gourmet toppings.

Having spent years exploring flavors and honing my palate, I’ve uncovered the heart and soul of New Albany’s pizza scene. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, I’m here to help you find your next favorite slice—because let’s be honest, the right pizza can turn an ordinary day into an unforgettable experience. So, grab a napkin and let’s dive into this cheesy journey together!

Frankie's Pizza & Wings

Highlights
Columbus Style Pizza
Crunchy and Crisp Crust
Delicious Pep-Pep-Alooza Pie
Tangy Sauce with Sweetness
Solid Pizzas with Customization

When I ventured into Frankie's Pizza & Wings, the tantalizing aroma enveloped me like a warm hug. Nestled in New Albany, this gem serves up Columbus style pizza, and let me tell you—it’s an experience worth savoring! The crunchy and crisp crust was the perfect foundation for the delectable toppings that awaited.

I took a dive into the Pep-Pep-Alooza Pie, a delightful creation that melded flavors harmoniously. The tangy sauce, with its subtle sweetness, danced on my palate, complementing the pepperoni and toppings in a truly satisfying way. What's particularly exciting about Frankie's is the ability to customize your pizza to fit your mood, making each visit uniquely delicious.

Each slice was a testament to the love and care that goes into every pie they create. If you’re in search of a pizza that’s not just good but exceptionally memorable, look no further than Frankie's. It's a place where the crust is crunchy, the sauce is tangy, and the overall vibe is just perfect for a pizza night out. I can confidently say that Frankie's is a must-try for anyone in New Albany craving an outstanding pizza experience!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Columbus.

Eagles Villa Pizza

Eagles Villa Pizza is an absolute gem in New Albany! From the moment I stepped in, the inviting aromas enveloped me, promising a delightful meal ahead. Their thin-crust pizza, perfectly baked and delightfully crispy, showcased a symphony of fresh toppings. I indulged in the classic Margherita, where every bite burst with the rich flavor of garden-fresh basil and rich mozzarella. The friendly staff added to the warm atmosphere, making me feel right at home. If you're searching for a slice of culinary joy, Eagles Villa Pizza is a must-visit—your taste buds will thank you for this delicious adventure!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap

At Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap, I was greeted by the charming aroma of wood-fired bliss. Their pizza, with its perfectly blistered crust, was a masterpiece of balance between crispy and chewy. I chose the signature Elliot’s Deluxe topped with savory pepperoni, fresh veggies, and a lush layer of melted mozzarella. Each bite was a delightful adventure, bursting with flavor that left me craving more. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff made it an experience to remember. If you're in New Albany and on the hunt for pizza perfection, don't overlook this hidden gem—your taste buds will thank you! 🌟🍕

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Brenz Pizza Co New Albany

Brenz Pizza Co New Albany is a delightful haven for pizza lovers! From the moment I stepped in, the warm, inviting atmosphere wrapped around me like a cozy blanket. The menu boasts a variety of unique toppings, but I decided to try the classic Pepperoni and the intriguing Buffalo Chicken. Each slice was a perfect balance of crispy crust and savory toppings. The homemade sauces added a delightful twist, making each bite a savory adventure. If you find yourself in New Albany, don’t miss the chance to indulge in their delicious offerings—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Columbus.

Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders

At Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders, I discovered a delightful blend of bold flavors and comforting vibes. Their handcrafted pizzas boast a thick, golden crust that’s perfectly chewy and crispy at the edges. I savored every cheesy bite topped with their zesty sauce, which makes the taste buds dance. The variety of toppings speaks to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike. The charming atmosphere adds a touch of warmth to the meal, making it a perfect spot for gatherings. If you’re searching for a slice of pizza heaven, Bellacino’s should definitely top your list! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Columbus.

Tony and Enzo’s Pizzeria

Walking into Tony and Enzo’s Pizzeria feels like stepping into pizza heaven. The tantalizing aroma hits you immediately, and the brightly colored decor welcomes you like an old friend. I ordered their signature Margherita pizza, and it was a delightful symphony of flavors; the crust was perfectly crispy, while the fresh basil and mozzarella danced together beautifully. Each bite was a reminder of the pizzeria’s commitment to quality. Service was friendly and attentive, making the whole experience even more enjoyable. If you’re searching for a slice of bliss in New Albany, Tony and Enzo’s is a must-try destination!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Columbus.

Mellow Mushroom New Albany

Mellow Mushroom New Albany is a whimsical haven for pizza lovers! From the moment I stepped in, the vibrant decor and laid-back vibe set the stage for a delightful pizza experience. I opted for their signature Holy Shiitake Pie, topped with a medley of garlic, mushrooms, and a drizzle of truffle oil—pure heaven! The crust was perfectly chewy, just how I like it, and the flavors danced in harmony. Their craft beer selection is the cherry on top, making it an ideal spot for both foodies and casual diners. If you’re craving a slice of creativity, Mellow Mushroom is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Gahanna Pizza Plus

Upon entering Gahanna Pizza Plus, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough hit me like a warm hug. I opted for their signature pepperoni pizza, which featured a perfectly crispy crust and generous portions of zesty toppings. Each bite was a delightful balance of savory and slightly spicy flavors, making it impossible to resist. The friendly staff added a touch of hospitality that made my visit even more enjoyable. If you’re on the quest for delectable pizza in New Albany, Gahanna Pizza Plus should definitely be on your radar—it's a slice of heaven worth savoring!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Aladdin's New Albany/Westerville

During my recent visit to Aladdin's New Albany/Westerville, I was greeted by a warm atmosphere and friendly staff. The pizza, a tempting blend of fresh ingredients and vibrant flavors, stood out brilliantly. The crust was perfectly crispy, offering a delightful crunch that paired beautifully with the rich sauce. Toppings were abundant, showcasing a symphony of ingredients that made every bite an adventure. I particularly enjoyed their unique take on the classic pepperoni, which added a delightful twist. If you’re looking for a pizza that combines flavor and comfort, Aladdin's is definitely a slice above the rest!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Zero's Pizza

During my delightful visit to Zero's Pizza in New Albany, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of fresh ingredients. The crust, perfectly crispy on the outside yet light and chewy inside, served as a wonderful canvas for their vibrant toppings. I savored the margherita pizza, which was bursting with flavor from the rich tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella. Their dedication to quality shines through, making each bite a little slice of heaven. As I left, a smile lingered, proving that Zero's truly knows how to elevate pizza to an art form—the epitome of deliciousness in New Albany!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Stadz Pizzeria Gahanna

Stadz Pizzeria Gahanna is a delightful gem that truly captured my heart and taste buds! The moment I stepped in, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough filled the air, promising deliciousness. I opted for their signature pepperoni pizza, and let me tell you, each slice was a symphony of flavorful tang and perfectly melted cheese. The crust had that ideal balance of crispiness and chewiness, making it delightful to devour. The staff's warmth added to the experience, making me feel right at home. If you're on the hunt for a satisfying slice, don’t miss out on Stadz! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Columbus.

Antolino's Pizza

From the moment I stepped into Antolino's Pizza, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough called my name. I opted for their classic Margherita, and it was an absolute delight – the tomato sauce danced happily under a blanket of creamy mozzarella, while the basil provided a refreshing burst. The crust was perfectly crispy yet chewy, a pizza lover's dream. Service was friendly, adding to the cozy atmosphere. Whether dining in or taking out, Antolino's undoubtedly serves a slice of heaven that keeps you coming back for more. If you're in New Albany, this gem should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.