The Absolute Best Pizza in Grove City [Updated 2025]

From the moment I stepped into Grove City, the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese enveloped me like a warm hug. There’s something magical about that first bite of pizza – the crispy crust giving way to gooey toppings, each slice a perfect harmony of flavors. After indulging in 12 of the top spots in town, I can confidently say that Grove City is a hidden gem for pizza lovers.

As someone who’s tasted slices from coast to coast, I’ve developed a discerning palate that knows the difference between a mediocre pizza and a masterpiece. Trust me, my taste buds have been through rigorous training! Join me as I unveil my favorite picks that will have you dreaming of pizza long after the last bite.

Grandstand Pizza Shop

Highlights
40 years of pizza experience
Loaded with cheese and pepperoni
Perfectly cooked pie
Spacious sit-down area
Thinner, non-crispy crust

When I first stepped into Grandstand Pizza Shop, the nostalgic aroma of pizza greeted me like an old friend. With 40 years of pizza-making experience, this place knows what it's doing! I opted for their signature pepperoni pizza, loaded with rich cheese and a generous amount of spicy pepperoni. Each slice was like a delicious hug, warm and comforting.

The crust? A delightful surprise! It’s a thinner style, not crispy but perfectly cooked, creating a wonderful balance between the toppings and the base. I found it easy to fold—ideal for those quintessential, messy pizza moments. The spacious sit-down area is perfect for relaxing with friends or family while indulging in your favorite slices.

As I savored each bite, I couldn't help but appreciate the dedication that goes into every pie. Grandstand Pizza Shop truly captures the heart of what pizza is meant to be: hearty, flavorful, and made with a passion that keeps customers coming back. If you're on the hunt for pizza in Grove City, make sure to stop by; their pizza just might become your new favorite treat!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Columbus.

Pizza Cottage

Highlights
Tasty Italian Sub
Varied Specialty Items
Inconsistent Customer Service
Delivery Order Issues
Not Responsive to Feedback

Pizza Cottage has certainly carved out a niche in the Grove City pizza scene—it's a cozy spot that promised much, but my visit was a mixed bag. Upon entering, the delightful aroma of freshly baked pizza tingled my senses, and I was excited to dive into their menu. What caught my eye was their tasty Italian sub, a delightful twist that added variety to their offerings.

Now, let’s talk about the main event: the pizza. I was thrilled to see a range of specialty items that turned my head, each one looking better than the last. However, I must admit, my experience took a turn when it came to the customer service. It felt a bit inconsistent; I encountered a disinterested staff that made the waiting game less enjoyable.

Furthermore, my delivery order was a minor fiasco, which unfortunately dampened my enthusiasm. To top it off, attempts to provide feedback were met with silence. Despite these hiccups, I still found myself appreciating the culinary charm of Pizza Cottage. They have potential, and if they harness it, they can certainly become a powerhouse in Grove City’s pizza landscape! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best burger in Columbus.

Broadway Plates and Pints

Highlights
Fresh ingredients
Outstanding food
Cozy and inviting ambiance
Exceptional service
Great lunch options

Broadway Plates and Pints truly stands out in Grove City’s thriving pizza scene. As soon as I stepped inside, I was enveloped by a cozy and inviting ambiance that makes it the perfect spot for a casual evening or a fun lunch outing. The décor strikes a delightful balance between playful and charming, setting the stage for what promised to be a great meal.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza! The crust is absolutely divine—crisp on the outside yet chewy on the inside, a testament to their commitment to using fresh ingredients. Each bite was bursting with flavor, and I could tell that a lot of love goes into every pie crafted here.

What impressed me even more was the exceptional service. The staff was not only friendly but also genuinely passionate about the food they serve, willing to make recommendations that enhance the experience. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, this place offers outstanding food that feels both comforting and exciting. If you're in Grove City and craving pizza, I highly recommend stopping by Broadway Plates and Pints—you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Joseppis Pizza Grove City

Visiting Joseppis Pizza Grove City felt like stepping into a pizza lover's paradise. The moment I walked in, the smell of freshly baked dough enveloped me, igniting my appetite. I opted for their signature pepperoni pie, and let me tell you, the crisp crust perfectly cradled a symphony of flavors—rich tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of spice. Each bite was a delightful dance on my palate! Plus, the friendly staff added a warm touch to the already inviting atmosphere. For anyone seeking a slice of Grove City charm, Joseppis is a must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Tammy's Pizza - Broadway Town Center

Tammy's Pizza - Broadway Town Center is a delightful gem that brings comfort and flavor to the forefront of Grove City’s food scene. The cheese pull on their classic Margherita is nothing short of legendary, with fresh basil that adds a vibrant pop. The crust strikes a perfect balance between crispy and chewy, making each bite a joy. The staff exudes warmth, ensuring that every visit feels like a homecoming. Whether you’re indulging in their signature pies or crafting your own masterpiece, Tammy’s is a must-try for any pizza lover searching for a slice of happiness in Grove City! Delicious!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Columbus.

Plank's On Broadway

From the moment I stepped into Plank's On Broadway, the inviting aroma of fresh dough and sizzling cheese engulfed me. Their signature sausage and pepperoni pizza struck the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, with toppings that danced together in perfect harmony. The slightly tangy sauce was a delightful surprise that added depth to each bite. Plus, their cozy, rustic ambiance made me feel right at home. If you're seeking a pizza that balances quality with comfort, Plank's On Broadway is undoubtedly a slice of heaven in Grove City. I can't wait to return for another round! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Columbus.

Zanzis Pizza Grove City

Zanzis Pizza Grove City dazzles with its crafted perfection and flavor-packed slices! Upon entering, the inviting aroma of fresh dough and sizzling cheese filled the air, setting the stage for an unforgettable meal. Their signature Zanzi's Delight pizza, topped with a vibrant medley of vegetables and perfectly seasoned pepperoni, was a delightful explosion of taste. The crust—golden and crispy—masterfully complemented the rich, zesty sauce. Plus, the staff radiated warmth and enthusiasm, enhancing the overall experience. If you’re hunting for a slice of bliss in Grove City, Zanzis is a must-visit for pizza lovers!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Columbus.

Roosters

At Roosters, the atmosphere instantly felt inviting, with a lively vibe perfect for pizza lovers. I opted for their signature pizza, topped with a tantalizing blend of fresh ingredients and a zesty sauce that made each bite a delight. The crust was perfectly baked, achieving that ideal balance of crispy on the outside yet chewy within. I especially appreciated their generous portioning, which makes each slice a true indulgence. If you’re in the mood for a fun dining experience, Roosters is definitely worth a visit. They serve not just pizza but a slice of Grove City's charm!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Tammy's Pizza - Hoover at Rt-665

Tammy's Pizza - Hoover at Rt-665 is a delightful gem for pizza lovers in Grove City. Upon stepping inside, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of fresh dough and savory toppings. I decided to try their signature pepperoni pizza, and it didn't disappoint! The crust was perfectly crisp, providing a satisfying crunch, while the generous layer of cheese melted beautifully with every bite. The zesty sauce added that extra oomph, making it a harmonious blend of flavors. With its cozy atmosphere and friendly service, Tammy's has certainly won me over—it's a must-try for anyone craving delicious pizza! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Flyers Pizza Grove City North

At Flyers Pizza Grove City North, I discovered a heavenly slice that sings with flavor! Their crispy, golden crust perfectly cradles a generous layer of zesty sauce and a melty blend of cheese that will leave you craving more. Toppings are fresh and plentiful, showcasing everything from classic pepperoni to inventive veggie options. The staff radiate warmth, making you feel right at home. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a feast, this charming spot delivers on both taste and atmosphere. In the race for the best pizza in Grove City, Flyers is a definite contender! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Flyers Pizza Grove City South/Commercial Point

The moment I stepped into Flyers Pizza Grove City, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me like a warm hug. Their hand-tossed crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy, creating a delightful platform for their rich, zesty tomato sauce. Topped with generous layers of gooey cheese and a variety of toppings, each slice is a burst of flavor that dances on the palate. I couldn't resist their signature pepperoni, which offers just the right amount of spice. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a quick slice, Flyers delivers a delightful pizza experience that’s sure to satisfy any craving!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Romeo's Pizza

At Romeo's Pizza, every bite feels like a scene from a culinary romance! The crust is a perfect blend of crispy and chewy, offering a delightful foundation for their generous toppings. I savored the classic pepperoni, which was a harmonious mix of spice and savory goodness. The sauce? Simply divine—rich and tangy, it provided a perfect counterpoint to the gooey cheese. The ambiance is inviting, making it a great spot for a pizza date or a family gathering. If you’re in Grove City and craving some irresistible pizza, don’t miss out on this charming gem! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Columbus.