The Absolute Best Pizza in Circleville [Updated 2025]

From the moment that warm, cheesy aroma wafts through the door, I’m transported back to countless late-night adventures and family gatherings, where a slice (or three) was always the centerpiece. I’ve savored every crust, from crispy to chewy, and tasted every topping imaginable while documenting my journey through twelve of Circleville’s top pizzerias.

So, whether you’re a die-hard pepperoni fan or someone who prefers a gourmet twist, you can trust my expertise born from years of delicious exploration. Get ready to discover the hidden gems and local favorites that make Circleville’s pizza scene truly special! Let’s dig in and find your next favorite slice!

City Barbeque

Highlights
Friendly and helpful staff
Dog-friendly patio
Delicious pulled pork nachos
Quality sweet tea
Varied sauces for every taste

During my recent culinary adventure at City Barbeque in Circleville, I discovered that this place is not just about delectable BBQ but also offers a unique take on pizza. The first thing that caught my attention was the friendly and helpful staff who greeted me with warm smiles, setting the tone for an enjoyable visit.

As I settled into their charming dog-friendly patio, I couldn’t resist starting with their delicious pulled pork nachos—a culinary delight that truly whetted my appetite. With every crunchy bite, I felt a wonderful balance of flavors that only heightened my excitement for what was to come.

Now, onto what purports to be their specialty pizza. While it’s not the traditional kind you might expect, the flavors were indisputably bold, enhanced by their varied sauces for every taste. As I savored each slice, I appreciated the quality sweet tea that perfectly complemented my meal, making the experience even more enjoyable.

So if you find yourself in Circleville, looking for pizza with a twist, City Barbeque deserves a spot on your list. Delicious food, a friendly atmosphere, and unexpected flavors await!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Columbus.

Pizza Cottage

From the moment I entered Pizza Cottage, the cozy atmosphere whisked me away to a world of cheesy delight. Their signature crust is a perfect blend of crunch and chewiness, making each bite a dream. Topped with their house-made marinara sauce and a delightful array of fresh toppings, the pepperoni pizza was nothing short of spectacular—bold, flavorful, and satisfying. I couldn’t resist trying their garlic knots, which paired beautifully with the marinara. If you’re hunting for pizza in Circleville, Pizza Cottage is a must-visit; their passion for pizza shines through every delicious slice! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Cristy's Pizza Circleville

Cristy's Pizza Circleville has become my new favorite spot for pizza bliss! The moment I stepped inside, the warm, inviting aroma whisked me away. I opted for their classic pepperoni, and let me tell you, each bite was a symphony of flavors. The crust? Perfectly chewy yet delightfully crispy, while the sauce had that just-right tang. The cheese? A gooey masterpiece that stretched with every slice! The friendly staff added to the experience, making me feel like part of the family. If you're on the hunt for the best pizza in Circleville, Cristy’s is a must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Gant's Pizza & Pub

Gant's Pizza & Pub is a delightful gem tucked away in Circleville, where every bite feels like a warm hug. The crust is perfectly crispy, providing a satisfying crunch that complements the rich, flavorful sauce. Topped with a generous layer of gooey cheese and fresh toppings, each slice is a testament to their pizza-making passion. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make it the ideal spot for a casual night out. Be sure to try their signature specialty pies; they are a true culinary adventure! Gant's is definitely a must-visit for anyone in search of pizza perfection. 🍕

You might also want to check out the best steak in Columbus.

Zanzis Circleville

At Zanzis Circleville, I was greeted by the warm aroma of freshly baked dough that immediately whetted my appetite. The pizza, a delightful blend of tangy sauce and savory toppings, was a true testament to quality. I indulged in their signature pie, where the crust struck the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. The vibrant flavors danced on my palate, leaving me craving more. The friendly atmosphere added to the charm, making it a splendid spot for pizza lovers. If you're in Circleville, don’t miss out on this gem—it’s a slice of heaven worth savoring! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Columbus.

Watt Street Tavern

Nestled in the heart of Circleville, Watt Street Tavern offers a delightful escape for pizza lovers. Their signature pies boast a perfect balance of crispy crust and fresh toppings that dance on the palate. I devoured the Pepperoni Deluxe, where the spicy kick was beautifully complemented by gooey cheese. The vibrant atmosphere, along with friendly staff, adds to the charm of this local gem. It’s a place where laughter and good food collide, making every bite memorable. If you're on the hunt for comfort and flavor, Watt Street Tavern is a must-visit for an exceptional pizza experience!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Columbus.

Donatos Pizza

Donatos Pizza in Circleville truly delivers a delightful experience! The thin crust is perfectly crispy, striking that ideal balance between crunch and chew. I sampled their Pepperoni Deluxe, and the generous toppings danced on my taste buds, singing a harmonious blend of spices. The sauce, with its zesty undertones, is the star of the show, bringing everything together beautifully. Each slice feels like a warm hug, comforting yet exciting. Whether you dine in or take out, Donatos is a must-try for pizza lovers. I'm already looking forward to my next cheesy adventure with them! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Roosters

Roosters in Circleville is a delightful surprise wrapped in cheesy goodness! The moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked pizza embraced me like a warm hug. I indulged in their signature pepperoni pizza, with its crispy crust and ample toppings that made each bite a party for my taste buds. The sauce had the perfect balance of tang and sweetness, leaving me craving more. Their laid-back atmosphere complements the fantastic food, making it an ideal spot for gathering with friends. If you’re seeking a slice of Circleville bliss, Roosters is undoubtedly a must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Pizza Hut

Stepping into Pizza Hut in Circleville, I was greeted by a warm ambiance and friendly staff. I opted for their classic Pan Pizza, and oh, what a delight! The crust was perfectly golden, crispy on the outside while remaining soft and fluffy inside—just how I love it. The pepperoni melted beautifully, creating a savory symphony with each bite. I couldn’t resist dipping the crust in a zesty marinara, which added a fun twist. Overall, Pizza Hut offers a consistent and satisfying experience, making it a reliable choice for pizza enthusiasts in Circleville. 🍕

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Goody Nook

Goody Nook in Circleville is a hidden gem that truly captures the heart of pizza lovers! The moment I stepped in, the inviting aroma of fresh dough swirled around me, sparking my appetite. I opted for their signature Mamma Mia pizza, featuring a perfect blend of zesty sauce and gooey cheese atop a crispy yet chewy crust. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors that left me wanting more. The warm, friendly atmosphere only enhanced the experience, making it feel like a home away from home. For a slice of pure happiness, look no further than Goody Nook! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

El Pedregal Mexican Restaurant

While primarily known for its Mexican cuisine, El Pedregal surprises with an unexpected twist: their Mexican-style pizza. Topped with fresh ingredients like zesty chorizo and vibrant peppers, it’s a delightful fusion that dances on the palate. The crust is light and crisp, perfectly balancing the bold flavors. Each bite feels like a festive celebration, transporting me to a sun-soaked plaza. Though traditionalists might raise an eyebrow, I found this flavorful creation to be a unique addition to Circleville's pizza scene. For anyone looking for a fun twist on pizza, El Pedregal is certainly worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Columbus.

Little Caesars Pizza

Little Caesars Pizza in Circleville is a delightful spot that delivers quick and tasty options for pizza lovers on the go. The iconic Hot-N-Ready pies are a lifesaver for anyone craving convenience without sacrificing flavor. The crust strikes the right balance between crispy and chewy, while the sauce offers a tangy kick that complements the generous cheese and toppings perfectly.

Their Crazy Bread is a must-try—oozing with buttery goodness and served with marinara for that extra zing. Overall, if you're after affordable, satisfying pizza without the frills, Little Caesars is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.