The Absolute Best Milkshakes in Columbus [Updated 2025]

As I took my first sip of a velvety chocolate milkshake, the rich, creamy texture enveloped my taste buds, and I couldn't help but smile. There's something magical about the perfect milkshake—it's like a sweet hug in a glass, transporting me back to carefree summer days. Over the past few weeks, I’ve scoured the city, indulging in countless shakes from 12 of the top spots, each with its own delicious twist.

With a discerning palate honed from years of taste-testing, I’ve narrowed down my favorites, and trust me, you won’t want to miss these gems. Whether you’re a classic vanilla lover or someone who craves adventurous flavors, Columbus has a milkshake waiting just for you!

Toft's Grand Scoop

Highlights
Deliciously diverse flavors
Friendly and patient staff
Cozy atmosphere for chatting
Decent portion sizes
Unique candy eye toppings

Toft's Grand Scoop is a delightful oasis for milkshake lovers. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere that feels like a warm embrace on a chilly day. The staff, ever so friendly and patient, made the decision-making process a challenge—how could I possibly choose among their deliciously diverse flavors?

After much deliberation, I went for a classic strawberry milkshake, adorned with whimsical candy eye toppings that made it truly Instagram-worthy. The shake was thick and creamy, and the flavor burst forth with each blissful sip, reminding me why I adore these sweet concoctions. Honestly, the portion sizes here are quite generous—perfect for sharing... or not (I won’t judge!).

As I savored my shake, I was captivated by the energy of laughter and conversation around me, making it an ideal spot for friends to gather. Toft's Grand Scoop encapsulates the joy of enjoying a classic treat, all while providing a charming backdrop. If you’re on the hunt for one of the best milkshakes in Columbus, I wholeheartedly recommend this gem. You won't leave disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Ritzy's

Highlights
Cool ambiance
Infectious staff interaction
Pay it forward board
Delicious smash burgers
Milkshake consistency issues

Ritzy's is a charming little gem I stumbled upon in Columbus, where the atmosphere is as vibrant as the milkshakes they serve. Walking in, I was immediately greeted by infectious energy from the staff—each member radiating a passion for creating culinary delights! With a cozy ambiance, it felt like I stepped into a delightful retro diner, perfectly suited for indulging in classic shakes.

Now, let’s talk about the milkshakes! While they boast a tantalizing array of flavors, I must admit, I encountered some inconsistencies. My initial sip was a luscious blend of creamy goodness while the next felt a tad thinner. Regardless, the rich taste often made up for the texture. What really stood out was their delightful smash burger, which paired beautifully with the shake.

One feature that warmed my heart was their “pay it forward” board, encouraging kindness among customers. It embodies the spirit of community! Overall, Ritzy's is a delightful stop for anyone in search of a memorable milkshake experience paired with genuine camaraderie. Despite a few texture hiccups, this spot deserves a visit for those luscious flavors and joyful vibes! What a treat!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Krema Nut Co

Highlights
High-quality products
Delicious spicy peanut butter
Small, charming shop
Variety of tasty snacks
Great customer experiences

During my visit to Krema Nut Co, a delightful little gem in Columbus, I was immediately charmed by its cozy atmosphere and the aroma of freshly roasted nuts wafting through the air. This quaint shop isn’t just about nuts; it’s a haven for milkshake lovers! I couldn't resist indulging in their signature milkshake, crafted with high-quality ingredients that deliver a rich, creamy experience with every sip.

What truly caught my attention was their unique twist—a spicy peanut butter flavor that dances playfully on the palate, leaving a lingering warmth that is absolutely addictive. Paired with velvety ice cream, it’s a perfect marriage of sweetness and heat, showcasing Krema’s commitment to using innovative and delicious ingredients.

Not only do they serve up a fantastic milkshake, but the variety of tasty snacks available means there's something for everyone. The welcoming staff made my visit even more enjoyable; their enthusiasm for the product is infectious. If you're searching for a whimsical milkshake experience, Krema Nut Co should definitely find a spot on your culinary bucket list. It's a delightful retreat where milkshake dreams come true!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Graeter's Ice Cream

Highlights
Nostalgic 1930's atmosphere
Friendly and polite staff
Tasty vegan options available
Relaxing and pleasant environment
Quick service with minimal wait

One sip of their delightful creations, and I was taken back to a time when joy was simpler—like enjoying the nostalgic 1930's atmosphere of Graeter's. The welcoming décor instantly transported me to a charming ice cream parlor, where friendly staff members greeted me with genuine smiles. Their warmth added a delightful layer to the experience, making me feel right at home.

I decided to indulge in a classic milkshake, crafted with their rich, creamy ice cream. The shake was decadently thick and perfectly sweetened, a true testament to their craftsmanship. What impressed me further was their inclusion of vegan options for those with dietary preferences. It's always refreshing to see amazing flavors catering to everyone!

Even though I was there during a busy rush, the quick service ensured I was sipping my milkshake in no time, with minimal wait—perfect for those on the go. The environment was relaxing, and it encouraged me to savor each velvety sip in peace. If you're on the hunt for an unforgettable milkshake experience in Columbus, look no further than Graeter's—where every milkshake feels like a celebration!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Shake No Eight

At Shake No Eight, every sip feels like a delightful adventure! Their signature milkshakes are creamy masterpieces, blending rich flavors with creative toppings that spark joy. I savored the Cookies and Cream shake, which was perfectly thick and speckled with generous cookie chunks. The whimsical decor adds to the charm, making each visit feel special. With a friendly staff eager to help you with your flavor selection, this spot truly embodies milkshake magic. If you're looking for a sweet escape, look no further—Shake No Eight is a must-try in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

The Yard Milkshake Bar

Stepping into The Yard Milkshake Bar is like entering a whimsical dessert wonderland! The towering milkshakes, garnished with everything from cookies to candy, are a feast for the eyes. I indulged in the “Reese’s Overload,” and each sip was a velvety embrace of rich chocolate and peanut butter goodness. The texture was impeccably creamy, and the flavors intermingled to create a deliciously decadent experience. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff only added to the charm. If you’re on the hunt for an unforgettable milkshake adventure, The Yard is a must-visit! Here, a simple dessert becomes a delightful masterpiece.

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Johnson's Real Ice Cream

At Johnson's Real Ice Cream, I dove into a delightfully rich milkshake that transcended the ordinary. The flavor was a perfect balance of sweetness and creaminess, with generous chunks of real ingredients mingling throughout. I couldn't resist the classic vanilla, which was anything but ordinary; it was reminiscent of blissful summers. The texture was smooth and thick, making each sip a luxurious experience. Pair that with their charming atmosphere and friendly service, and you've got a standout in the Columbus milkshake scene. If you're seeking a treat that feels like a hug in a cup, this is the place!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

Treaty Bear

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, Treaty Bear offers a whimsical twist on the classic milkshake. As I sipped their signature Peanut Butter Cup creation, I was enchanted by the perfect balance of smoothness and crunch. Each shake is a visual delight, topped with generous dollops of whipped cream and candy toppings that invite you to indulge. The bold flavors sing in harmony, making every sip a joyful experience. Not only is the ambiance cozy and inviting, but the staff also adds a sprinkle of friendly charm. For an unforgettable treat, Treaty Bear is a must-visit destination!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Diamonds Ice Cream

At Diamonds Ice Cream, I was greeted by a delightful array of flavors that danced in my imagination. I opted for the Oreo Cookie Crumble, and it was a treat for the senses! The thick, creamy base was perfectly blended, with generous chunks of Oreo that added a satisfying crunch. Each sip was a glorious adventure, rich yet refreshing. The inviting atmosphere, paired with their friendly service, made my visit unforgettable. If you're in Columbus and craving a milkshake that feels like a hug in a cup, Diamonds Ice Cream is a must-try. Indulge your cravings!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Columbus.

Smashburger

At Smashburger, the milkshake delightfully exceeded my expectations. I opted for their signature Chocolate Peanut Butter Shake, an indulgence that blended rich chocolate with a creamy peanut butter swirl. Each sip was a heavenly balance of flavors, and the whipped cream topping added a touch of whimsy. The thick texture ensured that every straw sip was a satisfying experience. Plus, the fun atmosphere made it a perfect spot to enjoy this sweet treat. If you’re in the mood for a milkshake that packs a punch, Smashburger is a must-visit on your Columbus milkshake journey!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.

Chocolate Café

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, Chocolate Café is a delightful haven for chocolate lovers. I indulged in their signature chocolate milkshake, a velvety concoction that dances on your palate with rich, creamy goodness. The swirl of whipped cream on top feels like a playful cloud, and the generous drizzle of chocolate syrup is simply divine! Each sip brings both nostalgia and joy, reminding me of childhood treats. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a sweet escape. If you're seeking a milkshake that embodies pure bliss, Chocolate Café should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

At Handel's Homemade Ice Cream, I indulged in their signature milkshake, and it was nothing short of heavenly. The creamy texture combined with the bold flavors created a delightful balance that kept me returning for more. I opted for the Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, which was bursting with chunks of dough and rich chocolate. The generous serving size felt like a warm hug in a cup! The joyful atmosphere and friendly staff added to the experience. If you're seeking a treat that feels both nostalgic and innovative, Handel's is a must-visit on your milkshake journey in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best fish and chips in Columbus.