The Absolute Best Deep Dish Pizza in Columbus [Updated 2025]

There's nothing quite like the moment you pull a slice of deep dish pizza from the pan, the gooey cheese stretching tantalizingly as you lift it to your mouth. The aroma of baked dough mingling with rich tomato sauce and freshly sliced toppings has become my personal love language. After devouring countless slices from twelve of the top spots in Columbus, I can confidently say that this city is brimming with hidden gems just waiting to be discovered.

Trust me, I’ve tasted the crispy crusts and rich fillings, savoring every bite with the kind of enthusiasm that only a true pizza lover can understand. So whether you’re a Columbus native or just passing through, get ready to indulge in a deep dish experience that will have your taste buds dancing!

Terita's Pizza

Highlights
Worth the trip
Best pizza in Columbus
Show stopper homemade sausage
Low key takeout location
Great Italian sub

Terita's Pizza truly delivers an unforgettable deep dish experience that makes it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Columbus. Stepping into the low-key, takeout-oriented space, I felt a sense of anticipation; the aroma of freshly baked pizza was simply irresistible.

With that first slice, I was in deep dish heaven. The crust boasted a perfectly golden, flaky texture that held up beautifully under the generous layer of toppings. Speaking of toppings, the showstopper here has to be the homemade sausage—it's a delicious explosion of flavor that elevates the whole pizza. Each bite was a balanced harmony of savory goodness and rich, tangy sauce that left me wanting more.

Besides the stellar deep dish, I couldn’t help but notice their great Italian sub, a solid option if you're in the mood for something different. Honestly, whether you’re a pizza aficionado or a casual eater, Terita's should be on your radar. Just know that after one taste, your standard for pizza will be forever raised! So if you’re in the Columbus area, do yourself a favor and check out this gem; you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Rubinos Pizza

Highlights
Unique immigrant style crust
Delicious, thick red pizza sauce
Mom & Pop pizza shop
Crispy crunch thin crust
Cash only, limited seating

Rubinos Pizza Review

Walking into Rubinos Pizza is like stepping into a warm embrace from a loving family. This charming little gem, known for its unique immigrant-style crust, had me intrigued from the get-go. As I settled into the limited seating—definitely worth the cozy crunch of community—I could already smell the delightful aroma wafting from the oven.

When it comes to their deep dish, the thick red pizza sauce is an absolute showstopper. It’s rich, flavorful, and generously slathered over the generous layers of cheese. Each bite is a reminder of home-cooked goodness, evoking blissful memories of family gatherings around the dinner table.

I opted for a classic pepperoni, which paired beautifully with their crispy, yet surprisingly thin, crust that offered a delightful crunch when bitten into. It’s the perfect balance of indulgence and heartiness. The knowledge that this is a cash-only mom-and-pop establishment only adds to its charm—no frills, just excellent pizza made with love.

If you’re on the quest for the best deep dish in Columbus, look no further than Rubinos; it's a slice of heaven that deserves a visit! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Giordano's

Giordano's in Columbus is a true gem for deep dish pizza lovers! Upon entering, the rich aroma of the oven embraces you, promising a delicious adventure. I opted for their signature stuffed pizza, and with each bite, I was greeted by a heavenly layer of cheese that stretched like a gooey dream. The robust tomato sauce, bursting with flavor, perfectly complemented the fresh toppings. The crust was a delightful balance of crispy and soft—truly a masterpiece! If you seek pizza that embraces comfort and indulgence, Giordano's is an experience you don’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Adriatico's New York Style Pizza

Adriatico's truly stands out with its heavenly deep dish offering. The crust is a delightful blend of flaky and buttery, providing the perfect base for a generous layer of rich tomato sauce. Each slice boasts an impressive medley of toppings that burst with flavor. I was particularly enchanted by the gooey, melted cheese that pulls apart with every bite, creating cheesy dreams. The ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for a cozy gathering. If you’re craving a deep dish that’s both satisfying and memorable, Adriatico's is definitely a top contender in the Columbus scene! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Paulie Gee's Short North

At Paulie Gee's Short North, I was greeted by a cozy vibe and a menu that sings with creativity. I opted for their signature deep dish, bursting with rich, tangy sauce and a perfect blend of oozy mozzarella and toppings. The crust? A buttery, flaky masterpiece that cradles the pizza's generous goodness. Each bite was a delightful adventure, showcasing their dedication to quality. Service was warm and inviting, adding to the overall experience. If you’re on the hunt for a deep dish delight, this spot should be at the top of your list! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Hounddog's Pizza

Hounddog's Pizza is a delightful tour de force in the deep dish realm! The thick, buttery crust cradled a treasure trove of toppings, and each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors. The rich tomato sauce had a perfect tang, while the generous cheese melted like a warm hug. What sets Hounddog's apart is their playful twist on classic combinations, making every slice an adventure. The cozy atmosphere invites you to linger, savoring each bite. If you're on the hunt for deep dish nirvana, Hounddog's is a must-visit destination that will leave your taste buds dancing! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Yellow Brick Pizza

Yellow Brick Pizza truly enchanted my taste buds with its magical deep dish creation. The crust was a delightful balance of crunchy and chewy, holding in a treasure trove of rich marinara and generously melted cheese. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, harmonizing with the fresh toppings that burst with vibrancy. The casual atmosphere made it a perfect spot to savor my slice. With every mouthful, I kept thinking, “This is definitely a contender for the best deep dish in Columbus!” If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and visit—it's worth the journey down the yellow brick road!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

Harvest Bar + Kitchen - Clintonville

Harvest Bar + Kitchen - Clintonville offers a delightful twist on the classic deep dish pizza. The layers of flavorful toppings are thoughtfully tucked beneath a perfectly baked crust that’s both crispy and soft. Each bite presents a wonderful medley of fresh ingredients, showcasing their commitment to quality. The rich, savory sauce is indeed the star, adding a delightful depth to the overall experience. The atmosphere is lively yet cozy, making it an inviting spot for pizza enthusiasts. If you’re craving a slice of joy that balances tradition with a modern flair, this gem is a must-visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Fibonacci's Pizzeria #1 (Studio 35 location)

The moment I stepped into Fibonacci's Pizzeria #1, I was enveloped by the inviting aroma of fresh ingredients and bubbling cheese. Their deep dish pizza was a delightful experience, with a crust that boasted a perfect blend of crunch and tenderness—truly the foundation of a great pie! The layers of robust tomato sauce and generous toppings created a symphony of flavors that danced on my palate. I particularly enjoyed the creative combinations available, elevating traditional tastes to a new level. If you're on the quest for a slice of decadence in Columbus, Fibonacci's is a vibrant stop you shouldn't miss!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Columbus.

Mikey's Late Night Slice

Mikey's Late Night Slice is a deliciously quirky gem that surprised me with its take on deep dish. The crust, perfectly golden and flaky, cradles a rich layer of cheese and a robust, zesty sauce that dances on your palate. I loved the generous toppings, each adding a delightful twist to the classic experience. The vibrant atmosphere made it even more enjoyable—who knew pizza could be this much fun? Perfect for those late-night cravings, Mikey’s proves that deep dish can be both satisfying and playful. If you’re in Columbus, don’t miss out on this slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.

Piece of Chicago Carryout

At Piece of Chicago Carryout, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked deep dish pizza. The crust was a delightful golden crust, perfectly crispy and holding the rich, savory fillings within. Its generous layers of gooey mozzarella and zesty sauce left me blissfully satisfied. The Chicago-style experience was spot on, with a symphony of flavors that danced on my palate. Their menu offers a variety, but I highly recommend the classic pepperoni—it's a must-try! If you're in Columbus and craving deep dish, Piece of Chicago Carryout is a slice of heaven you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill

My visit to Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill was an adventure in flavor! Their deep dish pizza, a veritable tower of cheesy goodness, left me utterly impressed. The crust was both crispy and buttery, providing a perfect foundation for the fresh toppings stacked high. I couldn’t get enough of the robust tomato sauce that harmonized beautifully with the rich cheese. Each bite was a delightful experience! The lively atmosphere only added to the enjoyment as I savored every morsel. If you're seeking a deep dish sensation that hits all the right notes, Beer Barrel is a must-try in Columbus! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best fish and chips in Columbus.