The Absolute Best Carrot Cake in Columbus [Updated 2025]

From the moment I take my first bite of a perfectly spiced carrot cake, I'm transported to a world where the sweetness of cream cheese frosting dances with the warmth of cinnamon and nutmeg. Each forkful feels like a celebration, and I’ve made it my mission to find the absolute best in Columbus. I’ve scoured twelve top spots, sampling slice after slice until my taste buds were in a euphoric frenzy.

Now, you might be wondering why you should trust my palate. Well, I’ve spent years honing my dessert detective skills, and each cake I’ve tasted has been a delightful adventure. So, grab a napkin and get ready—your next favorite slice is just around the corner!

Pattycake Bakery

Highlights
Always delicious and fresh
Friendly and pleasant staff
100% vegan options available
Comfortable atmosphere
Long-time favorite of locals

Review of Pattycake Bakery's Carrot Cake

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, Pattycake Bakery presents an unforgettable experience for dessert lovers, particularly for those with a penchant for carrot cake. As I wandered in, the pleasant aroma of freshly baked goods wrapped around me like a warm embrace. The staff, ever so friendly, welcomed me with genuine smiles, setting the tone for a delightful visit.

The pièce de résistance, of course, was their one-of-a-kind carrot cake. With each bite, the moist, tender layers danced on my palate, perfectly complemented by the heavenly cream cheese frosting that was just sweet enough to lift the cake without overwhelming it. They proudly offer a 100% vegan option, proving that indulgence does not have to compromise on values.

What I found particularly charming about Pattycake was the welcoming atmosphere—a cozy spot with eclectic decor that invites you to linger a bit longer. It's no wonder this bakery has become a long-time favorite for locals. Whether you're a vegan or not, I highly recommend treating yourself to their carrot cake; it's more than just dessert—it's a celebration of flavor!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Cherbourg Bakery

Highlights
Fresh baked daily
Best gluten-free options
Friendly and welcoming staff
Relaxed and inviting vibe
Reasonable prices

When I stepped into Cherbourg Bakery, I was immediately enveloped by the warm, inviting ambiance and delightful scents of freshly baked goods. This charming spot is renowned for its gluten-free options, making it a haven for those with dietary restrictions, yet still a delightful treat for everyone.

Now, let’s talk about the carrot cake. Each slice is a masterpiece, freshly baked daily, and bursting with flavor. The moistness of the cake is truly remarkable, with just the right amount of spices to keep your palate dancing. Topped with a creamy, rich frosting that melts in your mouth, it’s an absolute joy!

What adds to the experience is the friendly and welcoming staff. They genuinely share a passion for their craft, always ready to recommend their favorite goodies. The prices are quite reasonable, especially given the quality and freshness of the cake.

If you’re in the mood for a delightful carrot cake adventure, I wholeheartedly recommend a visit to Cherbourg Bakery. You might just discover the best version of this classic dessert that Columbus has to offer!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

Kittie's Cakes

Highlights
Cozy atmosphere
Fresh baked goods
Delicious breakfast sandwiches
Modern and fresh design
Friendly service and environment

Kittie's Cakes is a delightful spot that truly encapsulates the heart of Columbus. As I stepped inside, the cozy atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm hug, inviting me to indulge in their delightful offerings. The moment I spotted the carrot cake on the display, I couldn't resist its charm—it looked absolutely divine!

Upon my first bite, I was transported to carrot cake paradise. The cake was exquisitely fluffy, with a perfect balance of spices. Each forkful was a burst of flavor, enhanced by the freshness of the ingredients that clearly differentiate Kittie's from other local bakeries. This isn’t just a dessert; it’s an experience!

The cream cheese frosting, which often can be too sweet, was instead creamy and rich, brilliantly complementing the moist cake without overwhelming it. The kitchen clearly puts love and care into their baking, evident not just in the cake but in every corner of the bakery.

Add in the friendly service from the staff, and my visit became entirely memorable. Overall, Kittie's Cakes is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking the finest carrot cake in Columbus. Don’t miss out!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.

Highlights
Fresh and flavorful cakes
Easy online custom ordering
Astounding selection of treats
Moist and tasty scones
Highly recommended for occasions

— A Sweet Encounter with Mrs. Goodman's Carrot Cake —

When I first stepped into Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co., I was greeted by an intoxicating aroma of fresh-baked goods that could only mean one thing: I was in for a treat. Their carrot cake is a delightful standout that left me craving more. The moment I forked into a slice, I was enchanted by its moist texture and perfectly balanced flavors. Each bite had an exquisite blend of spices, and the carrots were fresh and plentiful, elevating the cake beyond the ordinary.

What truly impressed me was the simple online custom ordering process. It made it so easy to indulge in my cake obsession! Whether you’re planning a party or just looking for a sweet afternoon pick-me-up, their astounding selection of treats truly caters to every occasion.

And let's not forget their moist and tasty scones—they're the perfect companion for your coffee, rounding out an impeccable experience. Highly recommended for anyone in search of the best carrot cake in Columbus, Mrs. Goodman’s baking does not disappoint. With every bite, I found myself smiling and thinking, "This cake is a true gem!"

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Sadie Baby Sweets

Highlights
Custom smash cakes available
Delicious and beautifully crafted
Responsive and helpful service
Smooth and quick pick-up
Great for special occasions

At Sadie Baby Sweets, I discovered a delightful gem in the world of carrot cake. Their version is beautifully crafted, with a moist crumb that just melts in your mouth. What truly sets this cake apart is the rich cream cheese frosting, which is decadently smooth—perfectly balancing sweetness without being overwhelmingly sugary. Each bite transports you to cake heaven!

The service was as sweet as the desserts. I found the staff to be incredibly responsive and genuinely passionate about their creations. Whether you're picking up a cake for a birthday or simply indulging in a mid-week treat, the quick and easy pick-up process makes it all the more enjoyable.

What I particularly appreciated was their flexibility: Sadie Baby Sweets offers custom smash cakes too, ideal for those special occasions when you want to surprise loved ones with something extra special.

In the delightful land of Columbus carrot cakes, Sadie Baby Sweets undoubtedly claims a top spot. If you're a fan of flavors that are both comforting and exciting, make sure to stop by. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Matt's Bakery

Highlights
Delicious baked goods
Friendly and cheery service
Beautiful custom cake designs
Reasonably priced options
Convenient Kroger location

At Matt's Bakery, every visit feels like stepping into a flavor wonderland, and their carrot cake is no exception. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the scent of warm spices and sweet treats, paired with the cheery service of the staff that instantly brightened my day.

Now, let's talk about that carrot cake. It boasts a delectable balance of moistness and richness, with a hint of cinnamon that dances on the palate. The cream cheese frosting adds a delightful tanginess, creating a perfect harmony that keeps you coming back for more. I particularly appreciated the beautiful custom designs that adorn their cakes, making them not just a treat for the taste buds but a feast for the eyes as well.

Plus, with their reasonably priced options, indulging in a slice (or two) doesn’t break the bank. Located conveniently at a Kroger, Matt's Bakery is a hidden gem that truly stands out in the bustling Columbus culinary scene. If you’re in the mood for a slice of heaven, don’t miss out on their carrot cake—it's a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Kennedy's Kakes

Highlights
Great service and atmosphere
Easily placed online orders
Beautifully decorated cakes
Last-minute order convenience
10/10 taste and quality

Kennedy's Kakes truly surprised me with their delightful carrot cake, which is nothing short of a masterpiece. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the warm and inviting atmosphere—the perfect backdrop for indulging in some serious cake cravings.

What I absolutely loved was the ease of their online ordering system. With just a few clicks, I secured my dessert without a hitch, making last-minute dessert picking a breeze—because who doesn’t love spontaneous treats?

Now, let’s talk about the cake itself: I was met with a gorgeous creation that looked as good as it tasted. Each slice revealed layers of moist, spiced cake, generously interspersed with bits of fresh carrot and just the right hint of cinnamon. Topping it off was the divine cream cheese frosting—smooth and rich, yet not too sweet. It was the perfect complement to the cake's texture.

Overall, Kennedy's Kakes earned a solid 10/10 for taste and quality. Their commitment to customer satisfaction and cake excellence undoubtedly makes them a must-visit for anyone searching for the best carrot cake in Columbus.

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

The Bearded Baker

At The Bearded Baker, I encountered a carrot cake that danced on the palate. The moment I sliced into it, I was greeted by a moist, fluffy texture and a gorgeous swirl of cream cheese frosting that had just the right amount of sweetness. The addition of toasted walnuts provided a delightful crunch, enhancing every bite. Each forkful felt like a warm embrace, making it impossible to stop at just one slice. With a cozy atmosphere and a quirky charm, this bakery has truly crafted a carrot cake that’s worth celebrating. It's a must-try for anyone in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Resch's Bakery

At Resch's Bakery, the carrot cake is a delightful experience that dances on your palate. The cake boasts a moist texture, infused with just the right amount of spices, while the cream cheese frosting wraps it all up in a rich, velvety embrace. Each bite reveals a charming balance of sweet and tangy, punctuated with crunchy walnuts that add a delightful crunch. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect spot to indulge. If you’re searching for a carrot cake that combines tradition with a dash of whimsy, look no further than Resch's—it’s simply irresistible!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Columbus.

Bake Me Happy

At Bake Me Happy, the carrot cake is a delightful affair! Each bite bursts with fresh flavors, and the moist texture is utterly irresistible. Topped with a luscious cream cheese frosting that's perfectly sweet, it strikes the right balance without overwhelming your taste buds. The addition of crushed pineapple gives a surprising twist, adding to the cake's juiciness. The cozy atmosphere makes it a fantastic spot to indulge in this divine treat while enjoying a cup of coffee. If you're searching for a slice that embodies both comfort and artistry, this carrot cake might just be your new favorite!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Powell.

Mozart's Bakery and Event Space

Mozart's Bakery and Event Space truly impressed me with their heavenly carrot cake! The moment I took a bite, the blend of moist cake, crunchy walnuts, and succulent pineapple danced on my palate. Topped with a velvety cream cheese frosting, it was both indulgent and refreshing. The atmosphere, with its charming European flair, complemented the delightful experience perfectly. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just in need of a sweet treat, this gem is a must-visit. If you’re seeking the ultimate carrot cake in Columbus, look no further than Mozart’s—where every slice is a bite of bliss!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

TOUS les JOURS

TOUS les JOURS is a delightful gem in Columbus where carrot cake takes a delicious turn. The cake is wonderfully spiced, with just the right amount of moisture, making each bite feel indulgent yet light. The cream cheese frosting is a heavenly balance of tangy and sweet, lovingly slathered to perfection. I could definitely taste the fresh ingredients, and the addition of toasted walnuts adds a nice crunch. Overall, this charming bakery serves a carrot cake that is both comforting and sophisticated—surely a contender for the best in the city. Do treat yourself; it’s a slice worth savoring!

You might also want to check out the best fish and chips in Columbus.