The Absolute Best Bagels in Columbus [Updated 2025]

Each bite of a perfectly toasted bagel brings back memories of bustling New York mornings, the aroma of fresh coffee wafting through the air, and the satisfying crunch that gives way to a chewy, flavorful center. In Columbus, I set out on a delicious quest, sampling what this city has to offer in the bagel department.

With a taste test of 12 top spots, I’ve uncovered hidden gems and beloved local favorites that will make your taste buds dance. As someone who has traveled far and wide for the perfect bagel, you can trust my palate; I know what makes a bagel truly exceptional. So grab your coffee, and let’s dive into the bagel scene that Columbus has to offer!

The Lox Bagel Shop

Highlights
Complimentary customer parking
Consistently delicious food
Incredible Lox bagel option
Homemade sausage patties
Amazing artichoke spread

As I strolled into The Lox Bagel Shop, I could already sense that I was in for a treat. The aroma of freshly baked bagels wafted through the air, promising a delightful culinary experience ahead. This charming spot not only boasts complimentary customer parking—a rarity in the bustling city—but also prides itself on consistently delicious food that lures both locals and newcomers alike.

My taste buds were immediately captivated by their incredible Lox bagel option. Topped with silky cream cheese and rich, savory lox, each bite was an explosion of flavor that left me smiling and wanting more. And let's not overlook their homemade sausage patties; these were an unexpected yet fantastic accompaniment to my breakfast, offering a hearty twist to the meal.

But what truly stood out was their amazing artichoke spread. This delightful addition transformed my bagel into a gourmet dish, making it the perfect canvas for flavors that danced harmoniously. If you find yourself in Columbus and craving a bagel experience that feels as rewarding as it is comforting, The Lox Bagel Shop is a must-visit. Come for the bagels, stay for the smiles!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Columbus.

Bears Bagels

Highlights
Top-notch bagels
Great bagel sandwiches
Friendly and welcoming staff
Flavors that impress
Quick service despite lines

Visiting Bears Bagels in Columbus felt like stepping into a bagel lover’s paradise. The moment I crossed the threshold, I was greeted by a warm and friendly team that instantly set a welcoming tone. I quickly found myself mesmerized by their top-notch bagels, which are baked to golden perfection with that irresistible chewy texture.

Choosing my selection felt like a delightful challenge, thanks to their impressive array of flavors. From classic poppy seed to daring jalapeño cheddar, each bagel tempted my taste buds. I ultimately decided on a honey-wheat bagel — a choice that proved to be absolutely superb. The bagel sandwiches here are equally captivating; I relished a lox and cream cheese creation that balanced richness with a fresh bite.

Despite the lines, my order arrived swiftly, showcasing their efficiency without sacrificing quality. At Bears Bagels, it’s clear that passion and dedication to craft shine through every bite. Whether you’re simply stopping for a bagel or indulging in a sandwich, this spot offers an experience that is as delightful as the food itself. I left with a full belly and a wide smile, knowing I’ve discovered a true gem in Columbus.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Columbus.

The Roosevelt Coffeehouse

Highlights
Socially Conscious Mission
Inviting and Serene Ambiance
Diverse Coffee Selection
Artisanal Pastries and Bagels
Live Music Events

The Roosevelt Coffeehouse is more than just a place to grab a cup of coffee; it's a hub of community and warmth. As I stepped inside, the inviting ambiance wrapped around me like a cozy blanket. The decor is tasteful, filled with local art and a welcoming vibe, making it impossible not to feel at home.

Now let’s talk bagels—oh, the bagels! The craftsmanship is undeniable, revealing a skillful blend of tradition and creativity. Each bagel is a beautiful golden hue, boasting a delightfully chewy texture that pairs beautifully with their artisanal cream cheeses. I particularly loved the Everything bagel, which was a masterclass in flavor, as each topping sang in harmony.

One of the most charming aspects of The Roosevelt is its socially conscious mission. Every purchase contributes to community initiatives, making me feel a sense of purpose with each bite. And while I munched on my bagel, I savored the rich coffee selection that complemented it perfectly. The cherry on top? Live music events that wrap the experience in a delightful ambience.

In short, if you're searching for bagels that are not just delicious but also made with heart, The Roosevelt Coffeehouse should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Columbus.

Cornerstone Deli & Cafe

Highlights
Great variety of foods
Excellent atmosphere
Friendly and cool staff
Affordable sit-down lunch
Options for dietary preferences

Cornerstone Deli & Cafe is a gem nestled in the heart of Columbus that I was eager to explore, especially for their bagel offerings. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere that felt both cozy and bustling, a perfect spot to grab a bite.

Their menu boasts a fantastic variety, catering to all tastes, including options for those with dietary preferences—always a plus! I decided to try their signature bagel sandwich, which featured a freshly baked bagel that was the ideal blend of chewy and soft. The cream cheese was spread generously, with just the right amount of flavorful additions that elevated this breakfast classic.

What truly stood out was the staff; they were not only friendly but also knowledgeable about their menu, enhancing the experience with their recommendations. As the lunch rush swelled, it was impressive to see how efficiently they handled the crowd, making sure everyone felt welcome.

In terms of value, Cornerstone delivers an affordable yet satisfying sit-down meal. If you’re in Columbus and craving a delicious bagel, I highly recommend making a stop here! It's an experience that leaves you with a smile, and possibly crumbs on your shirt.

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Columbus.

Matt's Bakery

Highlights
Friendly and helpful service
Variety of delicious baked goods
Great for special occasions
Beautiful custom cake designs
Reasonably priced treats

Matt's Bakery: A Must-Visit for Bagel Enthusiasts in Columbus

From the moment I walked into Matt's Bakery, I was greeted with the warm and inviting aroma of freshly baked goods. The friendly and helpful service immediately set the tone for my visit. I was on a quest for the best bagel in Columbus, and I had a feeling I was in the right place!

Their bagels come in a delightful array of flavors, and I simply couldn't resist sampling a few. Each bite was a wonderful surprise, showcasing just how meticulously they're crafted. What truly stood out to me was the balance of chewiness and the perfect golden crust—this isn't just a bagel; it’s a masterpiece!

Additionally, Matt’s caters to special occasions with beautiful custom cake designs that would steal the show at any gathering. It’s a wonderful spot for those seeking a unique treat without breaking the bank. With reasonably priced delights, it’s hard not to indulge a little too much!

In conclusion, if you’re on the hunt for an exceptional bagel in Columbus, head to Matt's Bakery—you won’t be disappointed! I guarantee you’ll leave with a smile and perhaps a few extra goodies for later. 🥯✨

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Columbus.

Stauf's Coffee Roasters

Highlights
Highly recommended coffee
Delicious coffee cooler
Homemade in-house cookies
Super friendly baristas
Unique monthly specials

At Stauf's Coffee Roasters, I discovered a delightful blend of cozy atmosphere and delectable offerings. The moment I stepped in, the enticing aroma of freshly roasted coffee enveloped me, instantly setting the tone for what would become a memorable visit. Their bagels, made in-house, showcased a beautiful golden crust and a satisfyingly chewy interior that captured my attention right away.

Accompanying these scrumptious bagels, I couldn't resist trying their delicious coffee cooler. This refreshing treat paired seamlessly with my bagel, enhancing the overall experience. It's no wonder they have a reputation for serving some of the best coffee in Columbus!

What truly impressed me was the super friendly baristas who enthusiastically shared insights about their unique monthly specials. They clearly have a passion for what they do, which I found contagious. To top it off, indulging in one of their homemade cookies made the experience feel like a warm hug on a chilly day.

If you're exploring the bagel scene in Columbus, Stauf's Coffee Roasters is a must-visit. Their commitment to quality and community care shines through in every bite and sip. You won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Columbus.

Emmett's Cafe

Highlights
Exceptional breakfast burrito
Outstanding coffee by Ciell
Charming small atmosphere
Engaging seating experience

Emmett's Cafe is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, and it’s not just the bagels that steal the show. As I walked in, I was immediately charmed by the cozy ambiance, which creates an inviting atmosphere perfect for a leisurely breakfast. The standout here is the exceptional breakfast burrito, a scrumptious creation that rivals even the finest bagels. But don’t let that distract you; the bagels are simply divine!

I decided to try the everything bagel, a perfect blend of seasonings that captured every bite. It was freshly baked with the perfect chewiness and crisp exterior that I could only dream of. Paired with a smooth cup of outstanding coffee by Ciell, I was in breakfast heaven! The mindful attention the staff places on each detail added to the experience.

Aside from the food, the engaging seating experience invites friendly chatter and laughter, making it feel more like a community gathering than just another cafe. So, whether you’re in the mood for a hearty breakfast burrito or a bagel that sings on your palate, Emmett's Cafe deserves a special spot in any bagel lover's heart. Don't miss out on this delightful spot when you're in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Columbus.

Block's Bagels

During my visit to Block's Bagels, I was greeted with a charming atmosphere and an enticing array of freshly baked bagels. I opted for the classic everything bagel, toasted to perfection and layered with a generous smear of cream cheese. The bagel's crisp exterior and chewy interior danced delightfully on my palate. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, with the seasonings adding just the right crunch. The friendly staff also made my experience feel personal and welcoming. For anyone seeking a satisfying bagel experience in Columbus, Block's is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best bakeries in Columbus.

Fox’s Bagel & Deli

Fox’s Bagel & Deli is a delightful gem tucked away in Columbus, where the bagels are nothing short of heavenly! I sampled their everything bagel, which was perfectly toasted, offering a satisfying crunch that led to a chewy, flavorful center. The generous smear of cream cheese was a blissful complement, with just the right amount of herbs to elevate the taste. The cozy atmosphere made me want to linger longer. The staff’s warmth matched the delicious offerings, making it a spot I can't wait to revisit. If you’re on the quest for deliciousness, Fox’s should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Columbus.

Cocky’s Bagel Sandwiches

At Cocky’s Bagel Sandwiches, I was greeted by a delightful atmosphere and an impressive selection that made choosing a challenge. The bagels are nothing short of perfection—chewy yet light, with a generous array of toppings. I opted for the classic everything bagel, and it truly lived up to its name, bursting with flavor. Each bite was a celebration of carbs that left me wanting more! The friendly staff contributed to a positive experience, making this spot a must-visit. For a bagel that boldly stands out in Columbus, Cocky’s is an absolute winner in the bagel game!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Columbus.

Katzinger's Delicatessen

Katzinger's Delicatessen is a bagel lover's paradise! Nestled in the heart of Columbus, this deli boasts a delightful selection of freshly baked bagels that are both fluffy and flavorful. I savored their classic everything bagel, perfectly adorned with sesame and poppy seeds, paired with a rich, creamy schmear. The ambiance is warm and welcoming—ideal for a casual bite or a cozy catch-up with friends. Each bagel is crafted with care, ensuring a deliciously memorable experience. For a true taste of Columbus, Katzinger's deserves a top spot on your bagel quest! Don’t miss it!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Columbus.

Fox's Bagels North Market

During my visit to Fox's Bagels North Market, I was greeted with a lively atmosphere and a tantalizing aroma that promised a delightful experience. Their bagels are perfectly boiled and baked, boasting a crispy exterior and a chewy center that makes every bite irresistible. I indulged in the everything bagel, generously topped with poppy and sesame seeds—an absolute must-try! The selection of flavorful spreads, especially the chive cream cheese, added a delightful twist. The staff was friendly, enhancing the enjoyable vibe. Overall, this spot deserves a place in any bagel lover’s heart—and belly! Don’t miss out!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Columbus.