The Absolute Best Private Elementary Schools in Columbus [Updated 2025]

From the moment I stepped into my first classroom at a private elementary school in Columbus, I was captivated by the vibrant energy—the sounds of laughter mingling with the rustling of crisp pages, the bright colors of student artwork proudly displayed on the walls, and the warmth of teachers who genuinely cared about their students’ growth. Each of these schools has its own unique charm, and after exploring twelve extraordinary locations, I can confidently say that Columbus is brimming with exceptional educational opportunities.

You can trust my insights because I’ve not only visited these campuses but also connected with families and educators to understand what makes each school special. Whether you're looking for a nurturing environment, innovative programs, or a focus on academic excellence, I’ve gathered the essential details to help you find the perfect fit for your child. Let’s dive into this vibrant world of learning!

Calumet Christian School

Highlights
Small class sizes
Strong academic focus
Supportive community environment
Emphasis on Christian values
Limited extracurricular activities

Calumet Christian School is truly a gem in the heart of Columbus! Upon entering, I was immediately struck by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The small class sizes really stood out to me, as they allow for personalized attention, giving students the opportunity to thrive academically.

Calumet prides itself on a strong academic focus, which is balanced beautifully with its commitment to Christian values. This fusion creates a nurturing environment where students are not only challenged intellectually but are also encouraged to grow morally and socially.

One of the most charming aspects of Calumet is the supportive community that envelops the school. Families and staff alike work together, fostering a sense of belonging that is palpable in every corner of the campus. While I noted that the school offers limited extracurricular activities, the focus seems to be on ensuring that students develop a solid foundation in their academic pursuits and spiritual growth.

Overall, I left Calumet Christian School feeling optimistic about the educational journey it provides. With its emphasis on fostering a nurturing environment, I believe it’s a fantastic choice for families in search of a private elementary school in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best private high schools in Columbus.

Harambee Christian School

Highlights
Passionate staff
Strong community involvement
Engagement with students
Concerns about bullying
Issues with food quality

Harambee Christian School is a vibrant gem in the heart of Columbus that embodies a spirit of community and learning. From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I was enveloped by the passionate staff dedicated to nurturing young minds. The teachers here bring warmth and enthusiasm to their classrooms, making education not just a duty but a delightful adventure for the students. Their commitment extends beyond academics; they actively engage with families and the surrounding community, fostering a sense of belonging that is truly commendable.

However, as with any institution, there are areas for improvement. I noticed some concerns about bullying, which underscores the necessity for ongoing discussions about creating a safe, inclusive environment for all. Additionally, the food quality left something to be desired, as it felt more utilitarian than nourishing.

Overall, Harambee Christian School is a wonderful choice for families seeking a nurturing atmosphere and strong ethical foundation for their children. The community’s dedication to engagement and leadership fosters an environment where students can thrive emotionally and academically. It’s a place where learning is not just about textbooks but about building character. For those looking to plant roots in a supportive educational community, Harambee is worth exploring!

You might also want to check out the best spa in Columbus.

Columbus Torah Academy

Highlights
Strong community focus
Personalized learning plans
Emphasis on Jewish values
Supportive staff

Columbus Torah Academy is truly a gem in the realm of private elementary education in Columbus. From the moment I walked through the doors, I felt a palpable sense of community—a strong fabric woven from dedicated families and staff members who genuinely care about each child's growth.

One of the standout features of this school is personalized learning plans tailored to meet each student's unique needs. It’s refreshing to see educators keen on fostering individual strengths while guiding areas of improvement. The focus here goes beyond academics; there's a rich emphasis on Jewish values that permeates daily activities, teaching children the importance of kindness, respect, and community.

What really struck me was the supportive staff, who are not only highly qualified but also infectious in their enthusiasm for teaching. They create an inviting environment where curiosity is encouraged, making learning fun and engaging.

In essence, Columbus Torah Academy isn't just an educational institution—it's a thriving community where children can thrive both academically and spiritually. If you're on the lookout for a place where your child can grow into their best self, this school is definitely worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best schools in Columbus.

Mater Dei Academy

I had the pleasure of exploring Mater Dei Academy in Columbus, and what a delightful find it was! This school seamlessly blends academic excellence with a warm, nurturing environment. The educators are genuinely passionate, fostering curiosity while instilling values. I was particularly impressed by their innovative curriculum that encourages creative thinking. The close-knit community makes every child feel cherished, as if they belong to a larger family. With engaging extracurriculars and a commitment to character development, Mater Dei truly stands out. If you’re seeking a school that balances learning with joy, look no further than this gem!

You might also want to check out the best pedicures in Columbus.

Acton Academy Columbus

At Acton Academy Columbus, learning transforms into an adventure! Here, students embark on a journey of self-discovery through inquiry-based education that sparks curiosity and joy. The unique approach empowers children to pursue their passions while developing critical thinking skills. I was particularly impressed by the innovative learning environment, where collaboration and creativity thrive. The dedicated educators guide each child's path, ensuring a personalized experience that feels both engaging and inspiring. If you're seeking a school that embraces individuality and fosters a love for learning, Acton Academy might just be the perfect fit for your little explorer!

You might also want to check out the best middle schools in Columbus.

Almadina Academy

Nestled in the heart of Columbus, Almadina Academy offers a vibrant learning atmosphere that sparks curiosity and creativity. The dedicated faculty fosters a strong sense of community, ensuring each child feels valued and engaged. I was particularly impressed by their integrated curriculum, which beautifully blends academic excellence with character development. The diverse extracurricular activities provide ample opportunities for children to explore their interests. The welcoming environment makes it easy to see why families are drawn to this gem. If you’re seeking an inspiring educational experience, Almadina Academy might just be the perfect fit for your little learner!

You might also want to check out the best high schools in Columbus.

Wellington School

At Wellington School, the atmosphere buzzes with curiosity and creativity! From the moment I stepped onto the beautifully landscaped campus, I felt an immersive sense of community. The teaching staff exudes passion and dedication, fostering an environment where young minds thrive. Their unique curriculum blends academic excellence with a focus on character development, encouraging students to be both intellectual and socially responsible. Wellington's commitment to inclusivity truly shines, making every child feel valued. With its rich array of extracurricular activities, it’s clear that learning extends beyond the classroom. This school is a wonderful gem in the heart of Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best charter schools in Columbus.

Clintonville Academy

Clintonville Academy is a delightful gem in Columbus! With its nurturing environment and innovative curriculum, I was instantly charmed. The dedicated faculty encourage creative thinking and collaboration, making learning feel like an adventure. The school's commitment to fostering a sense of community is evident in every interaction—from enthusiastic students to supportive parents. The beautiful campus provides a perfect backdrop for exploration and discovery. If you’re seeking a school that balances academic rigor and a warm atmosphere, Clintonville Academy is definitely worth considering. It truly prepares young minds for a bright future!

You might also want to check out the best private high schools in Columbus.

Mansion Day School

From the moment I stepped into Mansion Day School, it felt like a delightful blend of learning and fun. The welcoming atmosphere and vibrant classrooms immediately captured my attention. With a strong emphasis on individualized learning, each child is nurtured to develop their unique talents. The dedicated faculty fosters creativity and critical thinking, creating young thinkers eager to explore the world around them. I was particularly impressed by their emphasis on character development alongside academics, which truly prepares kids for a bright future. If you’re looking for a school that feels like a home away from home, Mansion Day School is a gem!

St Joseph Montessori School

St. Joseph Montessori School is a delightful gem in the heart of Columbus! With its vibrant community and engaging curriculum, it provides an environment where children thrive. The Montessori approach encourages independence and exploration, allowing students to learn at their own pace. I was particularly impressed by the dedicated teachers who foster a love for learning through hands-on activities. The school’s beautiful outdoor spaces promote creativity and play, making it an ideal setting for young minds to flourish. Overall, St. Joseph Montessori School is an excellent choice for parents seeking a nurturing environment for their little ones.

Columbus School for Girls

Columbus School for Girls (CSG) is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Columbus! With a vibrant community and a focus on empowering young girls, the school's curriculum emphasizes creativity and critical thinking. I was particularly impressed by the enchanting campus and its dedicated faculty, who foster an environment of collaboration and curiosity. The small class sizes ensure personalized attention, allowing each student to thrive. CSG goes beyond academics, offering enriching extracurricular activities that encourage exploration and growth. Overall, Columbus School for Girls is a wonderful choice for families seeking a nurturing and inspiring educational experience for their daughters.

All Saints Academy

Stepping into All Saints Academy felt like entering a nurturing haven! The vibrant atmosphere buzzes with enthusiasm, where academic excellence meets a rich sense of community. I was particularly impressed by the dedicated teachers, whose passion for fostering curiosity is palpable. The curriculum is thoughtfully designed, making learning not just effective, but also exciting! Plus, the values instilled in students complement their intellectual growth beautifully. All Saints not only prioritizes education but also emphasizes character development, cultivating well-rounded individuals ready to take on the world. A gem in the heart of Columbus, this school is truly a delightful find!