Troy's Best Pizza [Updated 2026]

Because let’s be real—there’s nothing quite like a good slice to brighten your day, right? I’ve spent countless hours tasting, comparing, and savoring the flavors at twelve of the top pizzerias right here in Troy.

With my trusty taste buds and a passion for finding the perfect crust, I’ve uncovered some truly hidden gems and fan favorites that will have your mouth watering. Whether you're a die-hard pepperoni lover or someone who craves unique toppings, you can trust my recommendations to lead you to the pizza that will have you shouting, “This is the one!” So grab your appetite, and let’s dive into the delicious world of Troy’s pizza scene!

The Travelers Market

Highlights
Plentiful and delicious food
Friendly and helpful staff
Great local hangout spot
Flavorful drink options
Room for large parties

The Travelers Market in Troy is nothing short of a delight for pizza lovers eager to explore local flavors. As I walked through the door, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me, instantly setting the tone for a gourmet experience. The staff greeted me with friendliness that made me feel right at home; their passion for food was palpable.

One of the standout features of this charming establishment is its unique ability to cater to large gatherings. Whether you're celebrating a milestone or just hanging out with friends, The Travelers Market has ample space to accommodate groups without compromising on the quality of service.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. Each slice is a savory bite of perfection, thanks to their thoughtfully curated combinations of toppings. They even offer a variety of seasonal ingredients that elevate the taste to new heights.

Pair your pizza with one of their fabulous drink options for a well-rounded meal experience. Overall, The Travelers Market is an inviting haven for anyone seeking an exquisite pizza outing in Troy. If you haven’t stopped by yet, do yourself a favor—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best views in Columbus.

Blue Bird Deli

Highlights
Local deli with diverse menu
Outstanding customer service
Worth the wait for food
In-house Sloppy Joe delight
Must-try cheesecake brownie

Blue Bird Deli has quickly become one of my favorite spots in Troy, and I recently had the pleasure of indulging in their pizza offerings. This local deli stands out with a diverse menu that has something for everyone. Although it can be a bit busy, the outstanding customer service makes the wait worthwhile. The staff is always friendly and eager to guide your culinary choices—definitely a bonus!

Now, about the pizza: the crust is perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of chew. Each pie is a creative work of art, adorned with fresh, high-quality toppings that sing with flavor. I particularly enjoyed their specialty, which was a delightful experience that had me savoring each bite.

Of course, my trip wouldn’t be complete without treating myself to one of their in-house Sloppy Joes—a delightful surprise that added another layer to my meal. And I can’t forget to mention the must-try cheesecake brownie, which was the ultimate cherry on top.

Overall, Blue Bird Deli isn’t just a place for pizza; it’s a culinary adventure that you don’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Columbus.

3 Joe's Pizzeria and Trattoria

Highlights
Quiet and cozy atmosphere
Friendly and attentive service
Generous food portions
Delicious pizza options
Ideal for family dining

From the moment I walked into 3 Joe's Pizzeria and Trattoria, I was enveloped in a cozy, inviting atmosphere that offered a delightful escape from the hustle and bustle outside. The first thing that struck me was the friendly and attentive service—the staff treated me like family, ensuring I felt right at home.

Now, let's talk about the pizza! With a menu that boasts delicious options to satisfy any craving, I found it hard to choose. I settled on their classic Margherita, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly crispy, and the generous toppings burst with fresh flavors that danced on my palate.

Portion sizes were abundant, making it clear that 3 Joe’s values both quality and quantity, ideal for a fun family dinner. I can confidently say that this charming spot has found a place in my heart—thanks to the delightful ambiance, superb service, and mouthwatering pizza. If you find yourself in Troy and have a craving for some fantastic pizza, make sure to stop by 3 Joe's Pizzeria and Trattoria. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best dispensary in Columbus.

The Cellar by Bottle No. 121

Highlights
Largest selection of beverages
Wine tastings and live events
Friendly and passionate owners
Delicious cheesesticks and queso
Fun atmosphere with activities

When I stepped into The Cellar by Bottle No. 121, I was instantly enveloped by a vibrant atmosphere bursting with personality. Not only does this spot boast one of the largest selections of beverages in Troy, but it also provides the perfect backdrop for a casual evening out. The friendly and passionate owners made me feel right at home, which is always a plus!

Now, onto the pizza: it’s a party for your taste buds. While their regular menu is impressive, I couldn’t resist indulging in a few apps first — their cheesesticks and queso are wonderfully cheesy and addictive, making it hard to save room for the main event. But I pressed on!

The pizza itself was a masterpiece, with a tantalizing crust that strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. Each bite was filled with rich flavors that danced together brilliantly. Whether it’s date night or a gathering of friends, you can enjoy exciting wine tastings and live events that add an extra layer of fun to your meal.

In a nutshell, if you’re seeking an unforgettable pizza experience in Troy, look no further than The Cellar by Bottle No. 121 — it’s an absolute gem!

You might also want to check out the best malls in Columbus.

Crafted & Cured

Highlights
Unique multi-level experience
Excellent food and drink options
Great whiskey selection
Beautifully renovated old bank
Ideal for after-work hangouts

Crafted & Cured Review

Walking into Crafted & Cured felt like stepping into a beautifully restored slice of history—an old bank turned pizzeria. The airy, multi-level layout sets a delightful scene for both casual diners and after-work gatherings. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot to indulge in some exceptional pizza.

Now, let’s talk toppings! I opted for their signature pie, and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crisp yet chewy, a firm foundation for a harmonious blend of flavors. Each bite was a celebratory fusion of fresh ingredients, with just the right amount of cheese gooeyness. What truly adds to the experience is their impressive selection of craft beers and a stunning collection of whiskeys that complement every bite.

If you're looking for a pizza that excites the palate and an atmosphere that invites good conversation, I wholeheartedly recommend Crafted & Cured. It's more than just a meal; it's a culinary journey in a charming locale that will make you want to return for more. This gem is undoubtedly among the best pizza spots in Troy!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in Columbus.

Tipp City Pizza

Highlights
Fresh ingredients, amazing taste
Thin, crisp, perfectly baked
Delightful staff and atmosphere
Unique square-cut pizza
Perfect for family events

As I entered Tipp City Pizza, the aroma of freshly baked dough greeted me like an old friend. This cozy locale impresses with its vibrant atmosphere and welcoming staff, which sets the stage for an unforgettable meal. Opting for their unique square-cut pizza, I was immediately drawn in by the fresh ingredients artfully placed atop a thin, crisp crust that was baked to perfection. Each bite was a delightful harmony of flavors, making it clear that quality is a top priority here.

The variety of toppings offered is simply mesmerizing, allowing for endless combinations that cater to every palate. I opted for a classic combo of pepperoni and fresh veggies, and I was not disappointed. The savoriness of the pepperoni complemented the freshness of the vegetables, creating a mouthwatering experience.

Tipp City Pizza is an excellent choice for family events or casual gatherings with friends. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just on the hunt for a great slice, this spot has something for everyone. They really know how to deliver great taste and exceptional service, making it one of the best pizza places in Troy. You owe it to yourself to give it a try!

You might also want to check out the best shopping in Columbus.

Fulton Farms Inc

Highlights
Fresh and local produce
Friendly and knowledgeable staff
Charming farm stand atmosphere
Great for bulk orders

Fulton Farms Inc has a charming farm stand atmosphere that immediately draws you in. As I walked through the door, I was greeted by the friendly and knowledgeable staff, who were eager to share the story behind their ingredients. It became apparent that this isn’t just another pizzeria; it’s a celebration of fresh and local produce. Their pizzas boast crusts made from the finest ingredients, sourced right from local farms, which truly enhances the flavor profile.

What I particularly enjoyed was the unique topping selection, featuring seasonal vegetables that change throughout the year. This commitment to freshness not only supports local agriculture but also ensures that each bite is as crisp and vibrant as the last. The atmosphere feels like a slice of countryside serenity, offering a delightful escape from the usual fast-casual vibe.

If you’re planning a gathering, Fulton Farms is also perfect for bulk orders. The pizza is ideal for sharing, making it a hit at any event. All in all, my experience at Fulton Farms Inc was nothing short of a slice of pizza heaven—perfectly baked, flavorful, and undeniably fresh, it’s definitely a must-try in Troy!

You might also want to check out the best companies to work for in Columbus.

Long Shots Restaurant & Driving Range

Highlights
Delicious Ruben pizza
Great driving range experience
Clean environment and nice staff
Fair pricing for rentals
Perfect for food and drinks

Long Shots Restaurant & Driving Range is not just a place to sharpen your golfing skills; it’s also a hidden gem when it comes to pizza! As I walked into the bright and welcoming space, I noticed the delicious aroma that wafted through the air, promising a delightful dining experience. I decided to try their renowned Ruben pizza, a quirky twist on the classic sandwich that does not disappoint. The flavors melded beautifully – tender corned beef, zesty sauerkraut, and a rich sauce all atop a perfectly baked crust.

What sets Long Shots apart is the picturesque driving range that complements your pizza indulgence. You can enjoy your slice while taking in the fun and casual atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for both leisurely dining and post-game celebrations. The staff is friendly and attentive, enhancing the overall experience.

The prices are refreshingly reasonable, especially for a venue that pairs good food with a fun sport. Whether you’re a golfer or just someone in search of great pizza, Long Shots is definitely worth a visit. I left with a full belly and a big smile, convinced that this place deserves a spot among the best pizza offerings in Troy!

You might also want to check out the best townhomes in Columbus.

Los Pitayos Mexican Restaurant

Highlights
Excellent salsa
Top-notch service
Loved carnitas street tacos
Mixed reviews on tacos
Inconsistent food quality

Los Pitayos Mexican Restaurant might not be the first place you think of when it comes to pizza, but they certainly know how to serve up a delightful fusion of flavors that piques your interest! When I walked in, the vibrant atmosphere greeted me, and the top-notch service from the staff made me feel right at home.

While the focus here is primarily on Mexican cuisine, I couldn’t resist diving into their unique take on pizza—one topped with fresh ingredients that pay homage to traditional flavors. The standout was the salsa, which had just the right kick, bringing a delightful twist to the pizza experience. Though I’m known for my pizza critiques, I must admit the carnitas street tacos won my heart, offering a delicious alternative that I couldn't resist! However, I did hear mixed reviews about the consistency of their taco offerings.

While Los Pitayos might not be the epitome of pizza perfection, it serves as a charming spot in Troy where the unexpected can happen. If you're in the mood for a fun culinary adventure, don’t shy away from trying something different!

You might also want to check out the best used car dealerships in Columbus.

Pizza Dive

Highlights
Amazing vegan cheese options
Excellent customer service
Perfect for gluten-free diners
Popular wedding catering choice
Smooth and efficient operation

Pizza Dive in Troy is nothing short of a cheesy paradise! From the moment I stepped inside, I was welcomed by the excellent customer service that immediately made me feel at home. The staff's enthusiasm for pizza is palpable, creating an inviting atmosphere that makes you want to linger a bit longer.

One standout feature is their incredible range of vegan cheese options. As someone who appreciates all diet preferences, I was thrilled to discover that even non-vegans will be tempted by the rich flavors and delightful textures. Plus, their commitment to gluten-free options ensures that nobody feels left out.

What truly impressed me was their seamless operation. The efficiency with which they assemble pies makes it easy to see why they are a popular catering choice for weddings and events.

I haven’t even mentioned the toppings yet! From classic combinations to creative concoctions, every bite is a delightful experience. If you're in Troy and in need of a pizza fix, make sure to dive into what Pizza Dive has to offer—you won’t be disappointed! Their dedication to quality ensures that you’ll return for more slices!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Hilliard.

Miami County Fairgrounds

Highlights
Clean and well-maintained grounds
Great rides for all ages
Fun demolition derby
Tribute to veterans
Easy access for strollers

Miami County Fairgrounds offers a delightful escape into the world of fun and flavor! As I strolled through the well-maintained grounds, I couldn't help but appreciate the vibrant atmosphere—an ideal setting for indulging in some of the best pizza Troy has to offer.

One of the highlights of my visit was the array of great rides that cater to all ages. While the thrill of roller coasters and carnival games beckoned, it was the pizza that truly stole my heart. The fairgrounds often feature local vendors, serving up slices that are nothing short of heavenly. I savored a pepperoni pizza that was generously topped, with a crispy crust that had just the right amount of chewiness. Each bite was bursting with flavor, making it a standout I couldn't resist.

Adding to the experience, I admired the fairgrounds’ tribute to veterans—a thoughtful touch that adds depth to the festivities. Fairgrounds’ accessibility for strollers also made it easy for families to enjoy a day filled with fun and fantastic pizza. So, if you’re in Troy, don’t miss the chance to visit the Miami County Fairgrounds—where great rides meet delicious slices!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artists in Columbus.

Pizza Factory - Dayton's Original

Highlights
Unique specialty pizzas
Buy one, get one free Mondays
Friendly and quick service
Cooked to perfection
Plentiful toppings

Pizza Factory - Dayton's Original in Troy is a hidden gem that truly knows how to elevate the pizza game. During my visit, I was delightfully surprised by their unique specialty pizzas, offering interesting combinations and flavors that you simply can't find elsewhere. Trust me, the moment I took my first bite, I felt like a kid all over again!

Their buy one, get one free Mondays is absolutely a steal, making it a perfect spot to bring friends for a fun, casual evening. The vibe is welcoming, and the staff is both friendly and quick, ensuring that your culinary adventure starts off on the right foot. As for the pizzas, they are cooked to perfection, with a golden crust that provides the ideal crunch while remaining soft inside.

What truly stands out is the abundance of toppings—no skimping here! With generous portions, each slice is loaded, promising an explosion of flavors. If you're in search of a satisfying pizza experience, look no further than Pizza Factory. It's not just a meal; it’s a celebration of pizza in its finest form!

You might also want to check out the best divorce lawyers in Columbus.